Is Omaha Steaks Worth It

Omaha Steaks Review A Reliable Source Of Meat

CONTENTSTimothy Woods

There are countless online meat and steaks providers to choose from, and finding the right one can be tiring. And the moment you start reading those online comments, figuring out whats good and whats not tends to become an overwhelming experience.

Recently, we’ve tried Omaha Steaks, one of the largest providers. Let’s see how they stack up in that department, which will hopefully help you make the right choice for yourself.

Allen Brothers Vs Omaha Steaks

• How to Cancel Stitch Fix Quickly – July 19, 2022

Growing up, my family usually bought our steak at a grocery store- and occasionally wed treat ourselves to seafood from a specialty shop. But one year, near Christmas, someone sent us Omaha Steaks.

I remember the excitement of opening up the package, even though the meal itself wasnt as memorable. There was something special about having it delivered to our door. But a lot about Omaha Steaks, and Allen Brothers, has changed even since then.

For over a century, both Allen Brothers and Omaha Steaks have been serving American steaks and other favorite meats. Yet its exciting- and interesting- to see how theyve transformed.

No longer do you have to travel to Chicago or Omaha: now, both offer online delivery for everything from filet mignon to lobster. But I wanted to see how both companies quality holds up today- especially with a slew of options for organic meat and affordable patties.

Heres my honest look at the very real pros and cons of Allen Brothers vs Omaha Steaks. As much as both of these companies have become American staples for grill-outs and more, what I discovered gives me an idea of if either company is worth it for your next cooking event.

What Kind Of Nutrition Does Omaha Steaks Filet Mignon Have

Omaha Steaks filet mignon receives a D on the nutritional scale. The fact that this filet mignon contains very little salt works in its favor, but the high level of saturated fat and cholesterol are the two drawbacks of Omaha Steaks filet mignon. Filet mignon is an expensive cut of meat that does not contain much protein. 52 grams of filet mignon contains about 3 ounces of protein.

Filet mignon is considered to be the most tender form of beef steak and it is known for its richness. However, due to its high price tag, this meat option may not be suitable for those who are on a budget.

Omaha Steaks introduced the first ever Certified Organic Filet Mignon in 2004. This product is 100 percent natural and contains no added hormones or antibiotics. It is also free of any growth hormones. Unfortunately, this premium filet mignon still has a high amount of fat and calories.

The key to cooking delicious filet mignon is to buy top quality meat and follow a three-step process when preparing it: dry out the steak with paper towels, then brush it with oil and sprinkle it with salt. Finally, heat up a skillet over medium-high heat and cook it for 4 minutes per side for rare to medium-rare meat, 5 minutes per side for medium meat.

About Article Author

You May Like: Omaha Steaks Chicken Cordon Bleu Cooking Instructions

Also Check: Seasoning To Put On Steak

How Do You Select The Best Meat Online

Selecting the best meat online is tricky. Unlike shopping at a butchers or a grocery store, you cant inspect the meat yourself. The best beef, for instance, has a reddish color and even abundant marbling but is balanced so as not to be fatty. Theres also a different smell between fresh and older meat. So, ordering online takes a small leap of faith. Yet, it isnt a blind chance. Here are some factors I also consider when looking for meat online:

The Omaha Cut Ribeye From Omaha Steaks

Ive shared with you before about Omaha Steaks. I am proud to be an ambassador and Im a huge fan. Omaha Steaks has a stellar reputation as Americas original butcher. They are known for only the highest-quality cuts of meat, all delivered right to your door .

Well, they created a brand new cut of steak. In fact, it is so new and unique, that they are in the process of trademarking this steak. It will officially be known as the Omaha Cut. It is thicker, triple-trimmed, and perfectly sized.

Heres what Omaha Steaks told me about these new Omaha-Cut Ribeye steaks:

• BEST RIBEYE FLAVOR Ribeyes are exceptionally tender and exceptionally flavorful because they are loaded with fine feather marbling, which melts as the steak cooks, making it profoundly juicy and flavorful.
• PERFECT TRIM With the OCR, we take the very center of the ribeye and trim off all exterior fat so all youre left with is tender, juicy, ribeye bursting with flavor.
• THICK + TALL And even better, our Omaha Cut Ribeye is THICK. By trimming all exterior fat and cutting from only the center of the ribeye, we get steaks that are round and tallmeaning, you can cook it to its perfect doneness without fear of overcooking.
• PERFECTLY PORTIONED And you get all of this in a perfectly portioned steakno massive plate-sized ribeye here. Our Omaha Cut Ribeye is thick, juicy, tender, leaner, and flavorful, in just the right size.

What I Think of the Omaha Cut Ribeye

Read Also: Gas Grill Temperature For Steak

Do You Have To Thaw Omaha Steak Burgers

Omaha steak hamburgersyouthaw

. Considering this, can I cook Omaha Steak burgers frozen?

Put them into a zip lock baggie and submerge in warm water before cooking. Ignore the worriers who will say to use cold water. That takes too long and you will have them cooked fully well before 4 hours in the danger zone passes.

Likewise, do I need to defrost burgers? When times on your side, you can thaw your frozen burgers in the refrigerator, in cold water or in the microwave, according to the USDA. Thawing your meat in the fridge will usually require at least a full day, depending on the amount of meat youre defrosting. Foods thawed in cold water should be cooked immediately.

Subsequently, question is, do you have to thaw Omaha steaks before cooking?

Thaw your steaks completely in the refrigerator. While Omaha Steaks claims that it is possible to cook your steaks from a frozen state, the results will not be as delectable. Alternately, you can thaw your steaks in a bath of cold water for a quicker defrosting, for 30 minutes to an hour.

How long does it take for Omaha steaks to thaw?

Leaving items in their vacuum-sealed packaging, simple place them in a container of cold water to safely thaw your items more quickly. For example, using this method will allow for a Filet Mignons to thaw completely in 30-45 minutes.

Omaha Steaks Ran Into Trouble Over Their Website

When you hear about the Americans with Disabilities Act, it’s usually in reference to physical entities you know, things like wheelchair ramps, parking spots, or restroom accessibility. But one little known fact about the ADA is that websites also have a vague set of rules they must follow in order to be in compliance with the act.

Some advocacy groups have been known to take businesses to court if their websites aren’t easily accessible for blind users. However, because these rules aren’t quite set in stone , these cases are often gauged on a case-by-case basis.

See, if a business’s website isn’t rendered properly so that it can be easily read using text-to-speech software, that essentially leaves the website useless and inaccessible for someone who’s visually impaired or blind. The Omaha World-Heraldreported in 2017, that the advocacy group Access Now had partnered with three blind would-be customers to sue Omaha Steaks for a number of accessibility issues with their website.

The company, however, claimed that it was planning on doing a complete renovation job on the website later in 2018 and did not want to update its website until it rolled out the full update. The lawsuit was terminated shortly after it began, as the ADA is relatively vague with regards to internet compliance.

Recommended Reading: Chicago Steak Company Cooking Instructions

Company History And Mission

Chances are youve heard of Allen Brothers or Omaha Steaks or maybe both, even if youve never ordered from either. Thats because both have been around for over a century, and while I love that they have a long history of expertise, I wanted to trace how theyve transformed- and where they see themselves now.

I also think that their company mission statement says a lot about where their focus is. Plus, I wanted to see how their history and mission compare to their quality and service.

Where Does Omaha Steaks Source Their Meat

Unfortunately, Omaha Steaks does not make it clear exactly where they source their meats from. Even in their blog article here where they talk about why their beef is better, they dont exactly mention where it comes from. They speak very vaguely about how they select the beef and where it comes from. All of this is a bit discerning considering that Omaha Steaks markets themselves as high-quality meat but fail to mention what makes them high-quality.

You May Like: Ari’s Best Steak House

How Long Can Omaha Steaks Stay In The Shipping Cooler Before Spoiling

Weve left our meat in its Styrofoam container for upwards of 6 hours from when it arrived on our doorstep . So this means that the meat was in the cooler for over 30 hours and there was still a huge block of dry ice in it. My rule of thumb for anything being delivered frozen is to ensure it is frozen when I open the box or else I consider it spoiled and contact customer support.

Our Omaha Steaks Review

USDA Ungraded King Cuts Bone-In Ribeye 48 oz. – $110Bucket List SteakFilet Mignon served with Roasted Potatoes and Grilled Asparagus and a Grilled Onion HalfUSDA Ungraded Filet Mignon 10 Oz. – $23 King Cut NY Strip Steak served on a Bed of Grilled Onions with a Baked Sweet Potato and Sauteed ZucchiniUSDA Ungraded NY Strip 36 oz. King Cut – $80King Cut T-Bone Steak with Cheesy Potatos Au Gratin and Creamed SpinachUSDA Ungraded T-Bone Steak King Cut 48 oz. – $90USDA Ungraded Top Sirloin Steak King Cut 72 oz. – $120 ea.Bone-In NT Strip served with a Baked Potato and Corn.USDA Ungraded NY Strip Bone-In 14 oz. – $17Frenched Double Pork Chop with Grilled Red Potato Wedges, Broccoli Florets, and a Grilled Onion HalfPork Chops King Cut 16 oz. – $12Private Reserve NY Strip served with Mushroom Ravioli and Creamed SpinachUSDA Ungraded Private Reserve NY Strip 14 oz. – $28Sliced Chuck Roast with Sauteed Potatoes and Corn.USDA Ungraded Chuck Tender Beef Roast 2 lbs. – $20Beef Brisket Served with Seasoned Zucchini and Roasted CauliflowerUSDA Ungraded Whole Beef Brisket 12 lbs. – $99Braised Brisket RecipeOven Roasted Bone-In Prime Rib with Sauteed Breakfast Red Potatoes and AsparagusUSDA Ungraded Prime Rib Roast 6 lbs – $150Lobster Tails served with Red Potatoes, Corn on the Cob, and a Butter Lobster Tail BrothMain Lobster Tail Halves 2.5 oz $8.62 eaPan-seared Pork Tenderloin with Corn and Quartered Zucchini in Tomato SaucePork Tenderloins 9 oz. – $7.50 ea

Also Check: How To Make Ribeye Steak

How Is Omaha Steaks Shipped

After being packaged in Omaha Steaks Mini Deep Freeze made of polystyrene insulated coolers and a lot of dry ice, your order would likely be shipped from one of the two distribution locations in Omaha, Nebraska.

According to their customer service information, your steak would then be sent out in a temperature-controlled truck to your local UPS facility.

Shipping Delivery And Refunds

Trust me: shipping and delivery are one of the most important things to check if youre ordering steak, meat, or seafood online. My first step was to make sure that Allen Brothers and Omaha Steaks were clear about where they cover, their shipping carriers, and general delivery policies. I also wanted to check how meat was shipped to retain freshness and the process for refunds.

Also Check: Who Has Steaks On Sale

Omaha Steaks Reviews: What Do Customers Think

This Omaha Steaks review found a plethora of mixed feedback around the brands restaurants and online delivery service. From individual blogs to rating sites, there are definitely happy customers, but some concerns about quality as well. Lets take a look.

Tripadvisor reflected 2/5 stars from 66 reviews. One customer wrote about a positive comment on the brands prices and quality of steaks in 2018, When travelling to Omaha you have to make a quick stop to Omaha steaks and order yourself a package. Good prices and great Steaks.

Another agreed in a testimonial from 2020, after the pandemic had taken over, I anticipated a prolonged lockdown and I am so happy for my purchase. Everything I have cooked to date is perfection.

On the Better Business Bureau , 31 customer reviews left an average of 2.1/5 stars. Many customers noted that the quality was decreasing and the steaks were overpriced. There was one particularly scathing review, Some 40 years ago, it was pretty good. But, its so bad now that I cant see how theyve stayed in business.

Another echoed this sentiment, writing, These are very small and expensive steaks. The steaks are tough and stringy!

Fortunately, Omaha Steaks customer service is quite attentive, earning an A+ rating by BBB. All the comments on BBB received a response from Omaha Steaks, so it seems that they consistently resolve complaints from their consumers.

How Do You Cook Omaha Steaks

Omaha Steaks also offers cooking instructions, as well as a Steak Cooking Chart. Steak is recommended to be prepared one of three ways: grilling, pan-searing, or sear roasting. While you may need to adjust your methods slightly based on your steak choice, the following tips are recommended, as seen in the table below.

Read Also: Steak And Shake Com Careers

Is Omaha Steaks Overpriced

Omaha Steaks are overpriced according to some comments left on a couple of helpful review sites, such as Trust Pilot.

While some are disappointed, other commenters note that the items are of a high caliber and well worth the money. Per our review, the food is of reasonable value, and they still deserve a star rating.

The cost of each delicious cut you get to enjoy varies greatly, and you can find everything from the best quality Wagyu to lower-cost beef cuts to cook at home or eat in restaurants.

Some examples of price include:

For Under $100

• Steakhouse Sweet Potato Fries

The Easy Ordering Process Of Omaha Steaks

Their ordering process screams ease-of-use. The Omaha Steaks website is seamless! All you need are a few clicks to have your cart loaded up!

I received an order number for later review after checkout. It’s quite convenient because they accept a variety of payment options too!

Ordering food via a mobile device also turned out to be just as easy! You’ll have no problems ordering from Omaha Steaks if all you have to access the internet is your mobile device.

I’d like to point out that you have to pay attention to quantity throughout the process of ordering though.

Wondering why?

Ive found that depending on the item, in some cases at least, its actually cheaper to order eight pieces than it is to order 4 pieces of the same item.

You May Like: How To Barbecue The Perfect Steak

How Omaha Steaks Does Shipping

Omaha sends emails to notify you about shipping. It’s great since you know when to expect your entire order.

You can even select the optional phone alert which notifies you if the package has been delivered!

There’s also a chance to score free shipping depending on your order! Avoiding shipping costs is a HUGE plus when it comes to online meat delivery service since it’s often expensive.

Heads up though, ordering larger packages would obviously cost more. Thankfully, Omaha offers frequent discounts on their site!

Ever thought of giving steaks as a Christmas present?

They also offer a gift service that allows you to include a greeting card!

For Five Generations Omaha Steaks Has Been A Family Business

In the company’s century-long history, Omaha Steaks has remained a Simon family enterprise the current CEO and owner, Bruce Simon is the great-great-grandson of Omaha Steaks founder J.J. Simon. Simon has grown up in the family business and used to accompany his father to the plant as a child before working there during summer breaks from high school and college. This made Bruce Simon a natural choice to step into the position, as he had served various other positions within the company until 1994, when he became president and CEO.

Unlike other meat industry giants like Tyson Foods and Oscar Mayer, Omaha Steaks remains a privately owned company, meaning that investors cannot purchase shares of Omaha Steaks. While going public is typically looked at as a huge accomplishment for any major company, remaining a private, family-owned business has allowed the company to focus more on its long-term strategies, rather than constantly worrying about quarterly earnings.

Also Check: Philly Cheese Steak Meat For Sale