New York Strip Vs Ribeye: Taste Texture And Fattiness
Now its time for the important section: how good do the different cuts of meat taste?
Of course, the way that you prepare the meat, such as smoking or grilling will play a big role in how delicious the plated steak is. The following are just generalizations about the meat.
The short loin is an especially muscly area of the cow.
The result?
Its not as flavorful as a ribeye, nor is it as tender as a filet.
Its a chewier cut that has a decent amount of fat on the sides, yet nowhere near the amount of marbling you will find on a ribeye.
A New York strip is also typically a bigger cut of meat compared to a filet mignon.
If you want a bigger steak than a filet but not as fatty as a ribeye, then the New York Strip is your best bet.
A bone-in version of the New York Strip strip, which also includes a filet, is called a porterhouse, and is one of the biggest steaks youll find in most steakhouses.
Unless of course they serve a cowboy ribeye or tomahawk ribeye for two.
Where New York Strip And Ribeye Come From On The Cow
Beef comes from a cow, but its not that simple.
The location that the beef is taken from will change every major characteristic of the beef.
In the same way that your arm isnt the same as your foot, a New York strip isnt the same as a ribeye.
To start things off, heres a great video from Eater explaining where all the different cuts of steak come from on the cow.
Recommended Steaks To Order Via The Internet
Want to shop for steak from the comfort of your home or while you sit in the car waiting for a rainstorm to end . There are options a plenty out there. The one I would recommend is the Chicago Steak Company. I love the Chicago Steak company because…
1. They sell quality steaks that are either prime or top choice steaks including New York Strip Steaks. Their steaks are either wet aged or dry aged for improved flavor.
2. They educate people about steaks. Their Steak University site has a lot of helpful information on the subject.
I am always about finding a good deal on steaks. I have seen deals for free shipping and/or free steak burgers and around special occasions like Father’s Day. Check out the steaks from Chicago Steak Company.
Recommended Reading: Mcdonalds Steak Bagel Sauce Recipe
Price Of Filet Mignon Vs New York Strip Steaks
So now that you know all about the different cuts of beef, lets talk dollar signs.
The average price for each cut of beef will obviously vary depending on where you live, where you shop for meat, and what grade of meat you are purchasing.
There are three main grades of beef from the USDA and they are based on a number of factors but the most important one is fat content.
The main grades for steak are:
- Select
- Choice
- Prime (highest rated
While there is nothing wrong with select or choice cut meat for ground beef or stew meat, when it comes to steak, you definitely want to buy prime if you can.
While prime graded steaks are more expensive and a little harder to find you will truly notice the difference, especially if preparing a thick cut filet or ribeye steak,
The better steakhouses in the world will ONLY serve prime grade steaks.
For reference, we used pricing for prime grade cuts from and Bringhurst Meats for price per pound.
New York Strip Steak Sale
Celebrate dad this weekend by grilling some steaks! Head into Safeway for the New York Strip Steak Sale, and youll pay just $5.47/ lb. with a new Just for U Digital Coupon. Pair with the HOT Deal on fresh ears of corn just $.19 each with a Just for U Digital Coupon to have steak with fresh corn for dinner on Fathers Day!
The steaks are regularly priced at $14.49 per lb. Youll save $8.72 per lb, which is 60%!
Be sure to read our comprehensive guide to grilling the perfect steak here.
- USDA Choice New York Strip Steaks, Bone-in on sale for $6.77/lb. through June 22nd
- Load Just for U Digital Coupon for $5.47/lb. New York Strip Steak value Packs, limit 2 packages, exp. 6/22
- Final Price = $5.47/lb.
Add this item to your Safeway shopping list for grocery delivery or pickup, here or by clicking the buy now button below.
Recommended Reading: Mcdonalds Steak Egg And Cheese Bagel Recipe
How To Cook A New York Strip Vs A Ribeye Steak
As previously mentioned, any cut of meat is only as good as how its cooked and prepared.
Because ribeye is fattier than Filet, it does hold up to methods such as smoking a little better.
You can check out our favorite smoked ribeye steak recipe and method here.
For straightforward, everyday preparations though, heres what the pros suggest:
Where Do You Buy Your New York Strip Steak
I always look for grass fed, organic if possible, beef. I have an amazing Organic farm nearby, but I also love the steak at Whole Foods and Wegmans. And, each month, I get a box of grass fed meat from Butcher Box. Right now they have an amazing Valentines Day deal for free Grass Fed Steaks and Wild Caught Salmon with your first box!
Don’t Miss: How Long Will Omaha Steaks Stay Frozen During Shipping
Anatomy Of New York Strip
A New York strip comes from the short loin on a cow. This cut is right behind the rib and in front of the prize meats .
Like the tenderloin, the short loin is also comprised of a muscle. The big difference is that the muscle in the short loin, the longissimus, is much larger. The result is more meat from a single cut, and larger steaks.
Full Blood Wagyu New York Strip Steak
Not Available In Stores100% Full Blood Wagyu New York Strip Steak, also known as a New York Strip, Kansas City Strip or Boneless Sirloin steak, is versatile and irresistibly tender. Cut from the short loin, New York Strip Steak has the perfect balance of fat and muscle creating a luxurious dining experience.If youre looking for a steak to cook indoors or out, then this is the one. Whether serving as a steak, sandwich, fajitas or Asian cuisine, Wagyu New York Strip Steak has a clean, sweet flavor. Delicious and worth every penny, our Wagyu New York Strip will impress even the most discerning steak connoisseur.
Due to variations in our cattle weight, size, and color will vary by cut
Enhance your next event by creating a high end dining experience with 100% Full Blood Wagyu New York Strip Steak from Cross Creek Ranch!
Whether youre cooking this cut on the grill or in the kitchen, this New York Strip is sure to please even the pickiest eaters at your party.
These savory, flavor-packed steaks are the perfect addition to your dinner tonight and the compliments will keep rolling in long after youre done cooking.
Satisfaction Guaranteed with every order.
All prices are listed in USD.
Read Also: Omaha Steaks Delivery Tracking
Sterling Silver Premium Dry Aged Bone
*Monday through Friday only Description
Sterling Silver Premium beef is defined by its wonderful marbling and juicy flavor, incorporating the attributes of US Prime and the versatility of top tier US Choice Beef. Sterling Silver Premium Choice Beef includes the top 12% of all US Beef.
Also known as Strip Steak or Kansas City Strip its one the most popular cuts its one the most popular dry aged cuts. Tender, rich and flavorful meat prime steak lovers seek to cooked on the bone to retain all the juices. Full of flavor and very tender!.
Bone-In Striploins are Wet Aged for 21 days and then Dry Aged for 30 days for maximum tenderness and to concentrate a delicious rich, nutty and robust beefy flavor.
Each piece is cut with precision and poise by our veteran butchers. This attention to detail provides the highest quality mouth-watering New York Strip Steak every time you order!
- Grade: Upper Third USDA Choice or Higher.
- Aged: 21 Days Wet Aged + 30 Days Dry Aged.
- Weight: 16oz.
- Packaging: Individually wrapped & vacuum sealed.
- Gift Box: Delivered in a classic black gift box.
- Condition: Product is frozen before shipping to lock in flavor and will arrive frozen or partially thawed.
Grilling Ribeye And New York Strip Steaks
Both ribeye and NY strip steaks are excellent when cooked over fire or smoke. The seasoning should be kept simple due to the rich beefy flavor of these steaks. I like grilling high quality beef steaks over charcoal, but you will get great results with gas as well.
Cooking to medium rare at 130°F is really perfect. If you prefer medium well, cook to an internal temperature of 150°F.
There are two methods of grilling premium steaks. One is the two-zone method and the other is the direct grill method. We like the two-zone method for ribeye steaks and direct grilling for NY strip steaks. Well explain both in the recipes.
Recommended Reading: Omaha Steaks Dry Ice Disposal
How To Make New York Strip Steak
New York Strip Steak is a great lean beef option for the 21 Day Fix. Here are three ways to make New York Strip Steak at home on your grill, in your air fryer, or on your stovetop. This post contains affiliate links for products Im obsessed with.
My husband and I love a good steak especially on a date night or a weekend evening if we can manage to get the kids down early and enjoy a quiet dinner alone .
Although I love different cuts of steak, and tend to go with a Filet Mignon for really special nights, we received two New York Strip Steaks in one of our Butcher Box orders and I was surprised how much we loved them! Its a new favorite for us!
Steak Battle: New York Strip Steaks Vs Ribeye Steaks
Choosing the right steak is easy but not always straightforward. Some might think one cut of meat isnt different than the other, but thats not the case. Youre looking at marbling, fat content, fat trimmings, thickness, and other elements that go into picking out the perfect steak.
Choosing a grill-worthy cut of meat can make all the difference in your meal, but buying one doesnt have to be confusing. In this article, were putting two amazing steaks against each other to see which makes the cut .
Well look at the similarities, differences, nutritional value, and price of the two heavyweight steak champions the New York strip and the ribeye.
You May Like: Mcdonald’s Steak Egg And Cheese Bagel Nutrition
Best 8 Tips For Filet Mignon Vs New York Strip
Filet mignon and New York strip steaks are both great cuts of meat, especially when cooking on a pellet grill. However, these two cuts need special care on your pellet smoker.
In this article, well cover all the differences between a filet mignon and a NY strip, including price, anatomy, fattiness, flavor, and most importantly, how to cook them.
We also include two recipes for a smoked NY strip and a smoked filet mignon, so theres no guesswork when its time to slap your steaks on the grill.
New York Strip Steaks
USDA Black Angus Choice New York Strip
A classic among steak lovers, the Strip or Club Steak is one of the most popular cuts of beef. Offering rich marbling and succulent texture, the Feed the Party strip steak is a party favorite. Each steak is cut from only the finest USDA inspected Black Angus beef.
- 8 oz USDA Black Angus Choice New York Strip Cut Steaks
- Custom Packaging* Dry Ice + Cooler Shipped Right To Your Door
- 100% Born and Raised in USA. No Solutions or Additives. Pure Beef.
- Hand Cut from A.Thomas Meats in Louisville, Kentucky Since 1946
- FREE 4.6 oz Jar of Lanes BBQ Seasoning . *Limited Time Only.
You May Like: Walmart Steaks In A Box
Read Also: Pee Dee Steak House On 125
Tip: What Is A New York Strip
Although New York strips are delicious, they cant compete with a filet for flavor or tenderness. Theyre a bit chewier, with more fat on the sides and less marbling throughout the meat.
A New York strip with a bone is also known as a Kansas City strip, and a porterhouse steak contains a NY strip. If the T-bone steak only has a New York strip, it may also be referred to as a shell steak.
You might also know the infamous New York strip steak as a:
- boneless club steak
- Omaha strip
New York Strip Steak Basics
The New York strip is cut from the same muscle than runs along the rear end of the rib section, commonly referred to as the loin. The meat has a tighter texture and has less fat throughout than the ribeye. There is typically a tough band of fat that rests along one side of the steak.
While this cut is slightly chewier than the ribeye, it is still very tasty. NY strip typically costs between $9.00 and $15.00 per pound for USDA choice. Grass fed and organic portions will run a few dollars more.
The strip is a healthier steak when considering the fat content. That may be the tradeoff for less flavor and moisture. A 3 ounce serving of NY strip has 2.3 grams of saturated fat. There are 160 calories and 25 grams of protein.
Pro Tip #2: The New York strip is often sold under the names shell steak, Kansas City steak, or country club steak.
You May Like: Pee Dee Steak House On 125 Menu
Ease Of Cooking And Grilling:
As weve established, the ribeye contains more white fat flecks than the NY Strip. The marbling and drippings can cause flare-ups while cooking or grilling the beef cut.
For many grillers, this can make grilling or cooking the ribeye difficult. Nevertheless, since the NY Strip contains less fat, it tends to dry out quickly.
Anatomy Of New York Strip Steak
A New York strip comes from the short loin on a cow. This cut is right behind the rib and in front of the prize meats .
Like the tenderloin, the short loin is also comprised of a muscle. The big difference is that the muscle in the short loin, the longissimus, is much larger. The result is more meat from a single cut, and larger steaks.
You May Like: How Do I Track My Omaha Steaks Order
Price Of New York Strip Vs Ribeye Steaks
So now that you know all about the different cuts of beef, lets talk dollar signs.
The average price for each cut of beef will obviously vary depending on where you live, where you shop for meat, and what grade of meat you are purchasing.
There are three main grades of beef from the USDA and they are based on a number of factors but the most important one is fat content.
The main grades for steak are:
- Select
- Choice
- Prime (highest rated
While there is nothing wrong with select or choice cut meat for ground beef or stew meat, when it comes to steak, you definitely want to buy prime if you can.
While prime graded steaks are more expensive and a little harder to find you will truly notice the difference, especially if preparing a thick cut filet or ribeye steak,
The better steakhouses in the world will ONLY serve prime grade steaks.
For reference, we used pricing for prime grade cuts from and Bringhurst Meats for price per pound.
Battle Of The Brothers
These two steaks are often confused with one another and are alike in shape and size. This is because theyre from a similar part of the cow the longissimus dorsi, the two muscles along the spine and outside of the ribs.
The ribeye is cut closer to the neck along the upper rib cage. The New York strip, on the other hand, is taken from the short loin primal. This part of the cow is an underused muscle known for its rich flavor and very tender meat.
Like brothers, these cuts have a lot in common but are also different in many ways. Lets get down to the differences and see which cut is better.
Don’t Miss: Seasonings For Ribeye Steak
Tip: Filet Mignon Vs New York Strip Steak: Taste Texture And Fattiness Comparison
Filet mignon is heralded as the best cut of beef you can possibly get. It is juicy and tender, with great marbling throughout. You could even describe it as buttery.
Compared to a filet, a New York strip steaks contain less marbling in the meat and more fat around the sides. Once cooked, a NY strip steak is chewier than a filet mignon with slightly less flavor.
Background On My Meat Knowledge
Much of my meat knowledge has come from reading the Niman Ranch Cookbook. Besides having amazing recipes it has a lot of information on everything you wanted to know about meat and how it is produced.
I cannot recommend this book enough. It changed the way I looked at meat and helped me turn out some mouth watering meals in my kitchen. If you are interest in some really top notch beef and other meat recipes, I highly recommend picking up the Niman Ranch cookbook.
Read Also: Omaha Steaks Chicken Cordon Bleu Cooking Instructions
Best A5 Wagyu Beef For Sale Online
Originating from Japan, Wagyu beef is considered by many to be the best beef in the world. Like Kobi Beef, the luxurious taste and tenderness of highly-marbled Wagyu beef has the makings of a truly unrivaled eating experience, which is precisely why its found its way into the kitchens of gourmet cooks and fine restaurants across the United States. However, not all Wagyu beef is the same, as divergent cattle-farming techniques and country of origin vary in presentation and flavor profile.
If youre looking to buy the best prime gourmet beef online, our diverse Wagyu beef options are a succulent must-have. From Grass-Fed Tajima Wagyu beef to Australian Wagyu Beef for sale, we offer a vast selection of premium options ready to be delivered to your door.
