How Does The Price Compare
The prices of the Chicago Steak Company beef, steaks, and other meats vary greatly depending on the specific hand cut and the quantity of the meat you select and order. Still, based on our research, they are comparable to similar steak and beef providers offering the same caliber.
Their chicken and pork cuts are at the lower end, and on the higher end are their USDA Prime and American Wagyu beef cuts. Since this is all delivered meat, there are extra considerations, such as shipping costs, which we will get to later.
Some examples of pricing based on their best selling items include:
- USDA Prime Angus Beef Burger – 80z for around $100
- USDA Prime Steak Dry Aged Ribeye – 4 x 12oz Steaks for roughly $180
- USDA Prime Wet Aged Boneless Strip Steak – 4 x 10oz Steaks for about $150
Customer Support & Ratings
The company has high marks for service on various review platforms. While reading several Chicago Steak Company reviews, one thing that stood out to us was their open, helpful, and consistent communication with customers on Trust Pilot and Facebook.
Having a great customer service department is always a good sign that they are receptive to customer feedback. This, plus their satisfaction guarantee, gives them an easy leg up over similar meat delivery providers.
The quality of their product and top-rate customer service keeps me coming back to Chicago Steaks as a trusted source to purchase gifts and supplies.
-Rick, Trust Pilot Verified Reviewer
About Kansas City Steak Company
They first started out in 1932 as a family-owned butcher shop called S& S Meat Company.
They ended up growing in popularity and becoming a meat supplier for big retail businesses such as Outback Steaks and Carrabbas.
In 1984 they shifted focus and decided to venture into the mail order steak business, something that Omaha Steaks pioneered years prior. What eventually launched their mail order business was a deal with QVC to promote their products.
Since then, they have partnered with National Beef, who is the meat supplier for their Kansas City Steak Company online business. This means if you purchase from their online store, while the brand name is Kansas City Steak Company, the meat youre getting is actually from National Beef.
Also Check: Omaha Steaks In Store Specials
You May Like: Sam’s Club Steak Prices
Chicago Steak Company Reviews
Tasty good cuts a meat. Kinda pricey though. Free shipping is what helped me make my decision.
Date of experience:27 April 2015
Reply from Chicago Steak Company
We’re always happy when a customer enjoys our steaks Rodney! We do have multiple free packages that include free shipping and lots of discounted add on items for orders over $49. If you ever have any questions please give us a call and we’ll do our best to help 1-888-970-1118. Thanks and have a great day!~ Nicole
Whats So Special About Omaha Steaks
Omaha Steaks is perhaps the oldest mail-order steak company, but it didnt start as a delivery company. Omaha Steaks was founded in 1917 in Omaha, Nebraska, where it is still headquartered today. What was at the time a local butcher shop expanded into a mail order service in the early 1950s. By 1960, Omaha Steaks expanded its outreach by introducing vacuum-sealed packaging and dry ice to help the meat stay fresh for longer. A famous highlight was in 1961 when President John F Kennedy enjoyed Omaha Steaks. That year Omaha Steaks also earned acclaim at the Culinary Olympics in Germany.
Thus, Omaha Steaks established a glowing image of tender meat, customer service, and convenience. The question is: has that reputation held up, especially amidst competitors?
Also Check: Is Steak Ok For Diabetics
What Plans Does Butcherbox Vs Omaha Steaks Offer
In a delivery service, everyone is looking for something different, but typically flexibility is important as well as the option to cancel. For me, I prefer a good balance of both. I like the ability to select my own options but also the assurance I can easily change my mind.
- ButcherBox offers monthly and bimonthly plans, with the option to pause delivery for up to half a year, as well to cancel at any time before the next invoice, though they ask you to email rather than directly call.
- Omaha Steaks is a delivery service, but does not specialize in subscriptions. Their model is instead by individual orders. In that sense, ButcherBox is the true subscription service, and a bit more convenient.
Kansas City Steaks Prime Rib Roast Review
Kansas City Steaks Prime Rib Roast
When a prime rib is on the menu, theres cause for celebration. Its one of the best cuts of beef, is next-level tender, and packed with flavor. The Kansas City Steaks Prime Rib Roast comes in three sizes:
With gorgeous marbling of fat, this tasty, juicy roast is trimmed to optimize cost and texture. If youre not a fan of bones, dont worry, this roast is boneless. Its been aged for 28 days to pump up the flavor, but if youd like a little extra seasoning sprinkle with the Original Steak Seasoning packet included with your order.
Available for purchase in quantities of one or two, the luxury Kansas City Steaks Prime Rib Roast is $80-$240.
Also Check: Smoking Steaks On Masterbuilt Electric Smoker
Products Ordered Was Returned Due To Add
I NORMALLY ORDER FROM , AN AD WAS IN MY E-MAIL FOR CHICAGO STEAKS, I THOUGHT I WOULD TRY THEM. I SAW SOME DESSERTS THAT I LIKE AND PLACED A $115 ORDER, THE CUSTOMER SERV CALLED AND SAID THE ORDER I HAD PLACED WERE ADD-ON PRODUCTS AND THAT THE SYSTEM SHOULD NOT HAVE ALLOWED THEM TO APPROVE, SHE WANTED ME TO ADD ANOTHER REGULAR PRICED ORDER IN ORDER TO SEND MY ALREADY ISSUED ORDER, I REFUSED AND SAID IT IS NOT MY FAULT FOR YOUR SYSTEM ERROR, SO I CANCELLED THE ENTIRE ORDER. THIS WAS NOT GOOD CUSTOMER SERVICE TO ME ESPECIALLY @$115 DOLLARS FROM A RETIRED SENIOR CITIZEN ON SS. I PROBABLY WON’T USE CHICAGO STEAKS EVER, I TOLD YOUR REP I WOULD JUST GO BACK TO .SORRY I WAS NOT ABLE TO EVALUATE THE SERVICE BUT FROM MY EXPERIENCE THEY GET A 0 RATING AND I WILL NOT REFER THEM TO ANYONE HERE IN MICHIGAN.
Date of experience:14 March 2015
Reply from Chicago Steak Company
We’re sorry to hear about the confusion with this order Helen. After looking at the order notes I see all of the items on the order were “add on items.” These products significantly discounted and include free shipping because they’re not meant to be added to orders until the product charge reaches $49. I apologize if the phone call was mishandled as we do our best to make our customers happy. We do hope you will consider trying our products sometime in future and please feel free to call if you have any questions. Thank you and have a wonderful day!~ Karen
Chicago Steak Company Vs Omaha Steaks Comparison
Chicago Steak Company and Omaha Steaks are both hugely popular meat delivery services that go out of their way to keep their customers happy. However, they are designed with different carnivorous appetites and preferences in mind. To help you identify the strengths and weaknesses of both services and decide which one of them you should opt for, we have designed this convenient Chicago Steak Company VS Omaha Steaks comparison.
You May Like: Steak And Shake Franchise Investment
Final Verdict: I Would Choose Butcherbox Over Omaha Steaks
Bottom Line: ButcherBox, despite its reputation for high prices, has an edge over Omaha Steaks for the best value. Omaha Steaks does not provide information on sourcing, does not have as high of standards, and is not far cheaper as one might imagine. In addition, what should be the biggest benefit for Omaha Steaksthat is, flavor, is in fact not delivered.
The one area that Omaha Steaks does have an edge over ButcherBox is with its return policy. ButcherBox means risking $130-$150, and there is discrepancy in experiences when it comes to delivery and customer service. So proceed with caution.
Where to Buy: You can order from ButcherBox here, though as of late March 2020, they do have a waiting list.
Alternatives: Still looking for another meat delivery or meat subscription option? Check out recommendations for best organic meat delivery .
You can also read our more specific ButcherBox Alternative recommendations.
The Ingredients Needed To Make Cowboy Steak:
Cast-Iron Cowboy Steak Be the first to rate & review!Whether it’s a special occasion or just a nice weeknight dinner, there’s nothing quite as satisfying as cutting into a perfectly-cooked, restaurant-style steak at your own dinner table.Thick-cut steaks are reverse seared on the Traeger for a flavor injection, then topped with a zesty, herb-packed gremolata for a fresh finish.Before you get too confused, we’ll come right out and say it: the cowboy steak is technically a bone-in ribeye.
Recommended Reading: Walco Steak Knives Bone Handle
Final Thoughts: Who Is Omaha Steaks Right For
Omaha Steaks is one of the tougher reviews weve done. On one hand, their food is delicious and they have quite a lot of variety. On the other hand, the way they price their foods is confusing and can lead to one-off orders being very expensive.
However, my main gripe with Omaha Steaks though is their lack of transparency. Nearly every other meat delivery company we have reviewed in the past has been upfront about where they get their meat, the USDA grade of their meat, and the quality . It was nearly impossible for me to find any information about these things in my research.
With all that said, Omaha Steaks may not be the best value but they do provide the most convenience and variety when compared to nearly every other meat delivery service weve tested. This convenience and variety makes them a great option for people who are hosting big parties, holidays, or get togethers where there will be groups of people eating.
Plus, I cant deny that their food is delicious. Everything weve had in each box weve ordered since 2017 has had an abundance of flavorfrom the filet mignons to the chocolate lava cakes.
Have a questions about Omaha Steaks we didnt answer in this review? Have you tried Omaha Steaks before? Leave your comment below and well get back to you as soon as possible!
What Is The Main Mission Statement Of Kansas City Steaks Vs Omaha Steaks
Easily one of the most common factors to overlook is the general company mission statement.
This may not seem interesting or important, but what it does is give you an idea of what and whom this service is intended for. While you should never take a mission statement for its word, that mission statement should align with what is offered. Misalignment in this category can be a red flag.
Don’t Miss: Tyson Country Fried Steak Walmart
What To Know About Cooking
One of the big issues Emily and I ran into with Kansas City Steak Company was the cooking process. They give you a booklet that has all of the information needed to make everything from cooking your steaks to heating up the premade dishes.
When we went to cook the steak, we followed the directions outlined in the booklet since we wanted to make sure we were doing everything correctly so they would come out as delicious as possible.
Unfortunately, the was that the booklet lays out the steps, you have to jump between different pages for different steps. For example, on page 10 it tells us the partial instructions for cooking the steak on a skillet. Then you have to jump to page 12 to see how long you need to cook the steak. But on page 12, they have different cooking instructions at the top of the page.
But the most irritating part was that some of the steps dont have spacing between the words. I found it to be pretty tough to actually follow the directions properly because of this.
Surf And Turf Birthday Surprise
Ordered the Surf and Turf as a birthday gift. The package allowed for a free gift for me – a dozen burgers and steak seasoning. While completing the order form a field for two addresses was offered – one for the surf and turf and one for the freebie to me. However, both packages were sent to one address. When I contacted customer service it was explained to me that they do not allow two addresses . They did however offer to send me the burgers and seasoning as an apology for the inconvenience.
Date of experience:22 March 2015
Reply from Chicago Steak Company
Thank you for taking the time to share with us Sharon. We’re sorry to hear you were confused about the promotional items. I see that we sent the steak burgers and a bottle of steak seasoning to you as an apology. If you ever have any questions please feel free to give us a call at 1-888-970-1118 and we’ll be happy to help. I’ll make sure everyone receives a phone call as well as an e-mail in the future to prevent this confusion for any customers in the future. We appreciate your business and hope you enjoyed the burgers!~ Daniela
Recommended Reading: How To Order A Ribeye Steak
Snake River Farms Top Pick
Snake River Farms is a family-owned business out of Idaho whose meat is used by Michelin-star restaurants.
Luckily for us, they also sell directly to the public via their website.
Their claim to fame is their American Wagyu beef, which comes from crossbreeding imported Wagyu cattle with American Angus.
Their beef is rated higher than USDA Prime .
You can choose from a huge variety of cuts but you cant go wrong with ordering the American Wagyu Gold Grade Ribeye, the bone-in new york strip or the filet mignon.
They guys arent just a mail-order steak company. Porter Road is a full online butcher, selling a large range of beef, pork, chicken, and lamb.
Their meat is sourced from small family farms in Kentucky and Tennessee before it is cut and dry-aged for a minimum of 14 days at their facilities in Kentucky.
All beef is pasture-raised and hormone and antibiotic-free.
Their meat is also quite a bit more affordable than Snake River Farms, making Porter Road a great choice if you want to treat yourself without breaking the bank.
You can shop from over 50 different cuts of beef, but you cant go wrong with the bone-in ribeye.
One of the things I love about Porter Road is the selection of more interesting cuts like Flank Steak, Tri-Tip, Bavette, and beef neck roast.
You can also let Porter Road do the meat shopping for you with one of their curated meat boxes.
They are also focused on sustainability and ensure all meat is humanely raised.
Omaha Steaks Vs Kansas City Steaks: Quality Of Ingredients
Now, this is where things get a little bit trickier. Both brands are a little stingy when it comes to divulging where exactly their meat comes from and how its raised.
I do know that both brands have grass-fed products, but Kansas City Steaks primarily relies on corn-fed animals to get their cuts.
Im not making any headlines by saying that grass-fed is better than corn-fed, but that is the truth of the matter, giving Omaha Steaks a slight edge in this department.
Fortunately, I do know that both of the brands rigorously test for quality after the 28-day aging process.
Also Check: Is Omaha Steaks Grass Fed
Omaha Steaks Customer Favorites With Free Digital Kitchen Scale Vs Kansas City Steaks Tour Of Good Taste Review:
Omaha Steaks Customer Favorites with Free Digital Kitchen Scale
Name the top five most important kitchen utensils off the top of your head. Theyre probably a frying pan, a cutting board, a chefs knife, a good spatula, and a salt grinder among your selections.
Sorry to say pal, but youve got it wrong. The best kitchen tools are the foods you prepare. This section of my Omaha Steaks vs Kansas City Steaks review will compare each companys kitchen sink offerings, in that these are their sampling packs that deliver choices of their best products.
First up is the Omaha Steaks Customer Favorites with Free Digital Kitchen Scale. One of its obvious advantages is that it comes with a digital kitchen scale, an instrument I recommend for any home cook.
- 4 Omaha Steaks Butchers Cut Filet Mignons
- 4 Omaha Steaks Boneless Chicken Breasts
- 4 Omaha Steaks Burgers
- 4 Omaha Steaks Gourmet Jumbo Franks
- One package of Omaha Steaks All-Beef Meatballs
- 4 Omaha Steaks Caramel Apple Tartlets
- 1 jar of Omaha Steaks Seasoning
Now thats what I call a feast. If you order that item please invite me over for your next holiday dinner.
Kansas City Steaks Tour of Good Taste
Kansas City Steaks arent shy about their offerings though. The Kansas City Steaks Tour of Good Taste includes these select items:
- 4 Kansas City Steaks Strip Steaks
- 4 Kansas City Steaks Chicken Breasts
- 8 Kansas City Steaks Classic Steakburgers
- 1 Kansas City Steaks Original Steak Seasoning packet
- 1 Kansas City Steaks Cook Book
Oz Kansas City Strip Steaks
These were the steaks that we made in our review video above. You can see that they look fairly similar to the strip steaks youd find in your local grocery store. When it came to cooking them, we followed the instructions in the booklet they send along with the food but it ended up leading to them coming out pretty overcooked. While they still had some flavor, they were very tough to eat.
Recommended Reading: Save A Lot Steak Sale