Best Mail Order Steaks To Try In 2021
Last updated on by Adam Bryan. This post may contain affiliate links.
This post contains affiliate links which means that I will make a small commission if you purchase a product after clicking on any of them, at no extra cost to you. Thank you for your support.
Looking for an insanely easy and equally delicious way to order steak online? If so then you need to check out these amazing mail order steak companies thatll send you premium, fresh, and high quality steaks!
Below, youll discover some of our favorite mail order steak companies that you will absolutely fall in love with.
Plus they even make great gifts, especially for dads who love to grill.
So with that being said, lets just straight to our favorite online steak delivery services!
Best Complete Steak Dinner: Harry & David Backyard Dinner Party Meal
Courtesy of Harry & David
If youre planning a summertime cookout, but want all the grocery and meal prep done for you, you cant beat this steak dinner from Harry & David. The company’s Backyard Dinner Party Meal includes everything you need for a two-course steak dinner for four.
The kit includes four 6-ounce USDA choice top sirloin filets, peppercorn steak rub to season the steaks, cheesy twice-baked potatoes, zucchini and corn casserole, and a blueberry peach crisp for dessert. Cooking instructions are included. This is a great option to send as a gift to a family who just welcomed a new baby or returned from extended travel to an empty kitchen.
Now Direct To Your Door
Steaks that carry the name Fuego Diablo bear witness to a legend of taste and quality. Our Gold Label steaks are selected from the very best USDA Choice and Canadian AAA Black Angus Beef. USDA Prime and Canadian Prime is where we start with our Black Label Diablo steaks.
~ CLICK ON THE ICONS BELOW TO CHOOSE YOUR INDULGENCE ~
Offering the highest grade USDA Choice and Canadian AAA Black Angus Beef available.
Hand selected, hand trimmed and aged for 28 to 34 days.
Compare to Gibbys, Barberians Steakhouse, The Keg Steakhouse and Bar, Bâton Rouge Steakhouse and Bar.
Our Gold Label is the gateway to a better steak experience.
Only the top 2% of beef earns the coveted USDA Prime or Canadian Prime rating. And Prime is just the starting point for our exclusive Black Label.
Hand selected, hand trimmed and aged for 28 to 40 days.
Mortons The Steakhouse, Keens Steakhouse, and HYs Steakhouse are all known for serving Prime Grade beef.
For those tempted into the darkness of our Black Label, there will be no return.
You May Like: 8 Slot Steak Knife Block
Read Also: Where To Find Hanger Steak
Is It Cheaper Or More Expensive To Buy Meat On The Internet
The meat you buy from internet butchers is of very high quality and is often delivered to some of Americas finest restaurants. So, obviously, it will cost more than meat in local stores. But the quality and marbling of the meat you get are worth it.
And that makes sense. People who search for steak on the internet usually want grass-fed beef, Wagyu, or other meat of the best quality. Fortunately, we have selected companies from the more expensive and more affordable segment for you, so you can find a steak that will be within your pocket anyway.
What Companies Sell Exotic And Wild Game Meat
Fossil Farms, Wild Fork, and Broken Arrow Ranch are a few companies that sell wild game meat. Some specialize in meats such as bison and elk while others provide rarer game meats such as antelope, kangaroo, and wild boar. Most companies ship meats that are flash frozen. Minimum orders and shipping costs vary.
Don’t Miss: Steak Marinade With Montreal Steak Seasoning
Pick #: Snake River Farms
A close runner-up to Porter Road steaks is Snake River Farms. Snake River Farms has been breeding quality meat since the 1980s and is known around the country for its American Wagyu steaks. All animals are raised humanely and are bred to the finest beef standards.
Snake River Farms has a wide variety of beef cuts, some of which you cant find anywhere else. They are a bit on the pricey side, but every steak you order will be 100% worth it. They also frequently run specials and have a loyalty program.
The only downside of Snake River Farms is that they freeze their beef in order to ship it to you. This is for safety reasons, but it can detract from the taste of the beef slightly. But there is nowhere else to order American Wagyu, so if thats what you want, this is the place!
Pros
Best Seafood Delivery: Fulton Fish Market
Whether you follow a pescatarian lifestyle or simply enjoy eating fish and shellfish, consider the best seafood delivery service: Fulton Fish Market. The company offers subscription boxes for weekly, biweekly, or monthly delivery, plus a wide selection of fish, shellfish, and specialty seafoodâsuch as caviar, eel, and octopusâthat you can buy individually. Fulton Fish Market is also a great place to shop fish-friendly pantry items like cedar planks for grilling and sauces for enhancing flavors. And if you want to stock up for a good price, check out the seafood bundles starting at $35.
To make your online shopping trip a breeze, you can filter the seafood by cut, preparation, and price. Fulton Fish Market mostly ships fresh seafood, but it also has frozen, salted, and smoked delivery options. As far as selection goesâyou name it, Fulton Market probably has it. A la carte prices start at $5 for one piece of silver-skinned branzino and go all the way up to $715 for a 6.5-pound Copper River king salmon. Luckily, most cuts of fish cost under $100.
Recommended Reading: Taste Of Texas Steak Knives
Best For Premium Meat: Snake River Farms
Snake River Farms offers complete lines of gourmet Kurobuta pork and American Wagyu beef sourced from sustainable family farms in the Northwest. Serious home cooks will love Snake River Farms’ variety of fine cuts and its recipe section that features dishes from some of the world’s top chefs. Snake River Farms ships its meats frozen and vacuum-sealed in compostable packaging.
Sure, premium meats are on the pricier side, but your tastebuds will thank you. American Wagyu beef is considered a delicacy because of its rich marbling and tender texture, and Kurobuta pork comes from heritage breeds known for their intense flavor and juiciness. In the American Wagyu Beef shop, you can buy steaks , ribs, brisket, roasts, burgers, and hot dogs. As for the Kurobuta pork options, there are pork chops, ham, ribs, roasts, and bacon available. Prices start at $12 for one pound of Wagyu hot dogs and go up to $1,049 for a limited 16-pound Wagyu dry-aged bone-in prime rib. If you want to order steaks online, one eight-ounce Wagyu top sirloin costs $20.
Is Organic Or Grass
Another difference in how healthy your meat is? Sourcing. If youre just entertaining or gifting, you may be less selective. But for many, buying organic or grass-fed results in fresher tasting meat, healthier meat, and more sustainable and ethical meat. But theres a good deal of confusion with these terms.
Grass-fed beef usually is a good sign, but it is not the same as free pasture beef. That is, grass-fed beef tends to be healthier both for the animal and you with more lean mass and less fat. Grass-fed beef can also have as much as 5 times healthy fats as grain-fed beef it just doesnt guarantee that they arent still cooped up most of their lives.
Organic beef goes a step further and ensures that animals cannot be raised in crowded or unsanitary conditions, and they must have some room to roam. So the optimal is grass-fed and organic beef but this can be tricky to find. And, of course, itll be more expensive.
You May Like: Serrated Vs Non Serrated Steak Knives
Best For Organic Meat: Rastelli’s
-
Meats raised without hormones and steroids
-
Partners with longtime family farms
-
Organic whole chickens and cuts
-
Free shipping only for orders over $200
What started as a small butcher shop has evolved into one of the best places to buy meat online, especially if you are searching for organic chicken. Rastellis is passionate about helping customers better trace where their food comes from by partnering with longstanding family farms that prioritize animal welfare and product quality. Rastellis meats are certified antibiotic, hormone, and steroid free. The organic chicken comes from chickens that are pasture-raised and fed GMO-free feed.
Rastellis meats are vacuum sealed and then blast frozen for peak freshness upon arrival. The meat will stay fresh for up to a year in your freezer. All Rastellis meats are available for one-time purchase, but you can also subscribe for deliveries every one, two, three, four, or six weeks. There is no minimum order, but the less you buy, the more youll pay for shipping. Only orders over $200 ship free, while orders under $100 cost $25 to ship and orders between $100 and $199 ship for $10.
How We Chose The Best Meat Delivery Services
Here at Forbes Vetted, we scour the market to make sure were only recommending the best of the bestand those same standards were upheld as we crafted this list of the best meat delivery services. We sorted through thousands of firsthand reviews from consumers, compared prices and generally determined whether the services we selected were of an exceptionally high value. This story was last updated in September 2022.
Also Check: 8 Oz Wagyu Steak Price
Celebrate With Fillet Steak Delivered To Your Door
Melt-in-the-mouth and supremely lean, fillet steak cooked to perfection is synonymous with great meat at its most tender.
Hailed as one of the highest ranking cuts in the steak hierarchy, this deliciously decadent piece of meat remains one of our most popular orders and it can be yours at the click of a button.
Make sure our fillet steak graces your next online steak order.
GET 10% OFF your first order and learn more about healthy food from sustainable farms
Sign up to our weekly newsletter and your 10% discount code will then be emailed to you.
we support
Best For Wagyu Beef: Crowd Cow
This site was inspired by the concept of purchasing meat directly from a local farmeronly instead of having to buy, transport, and store an entire cow yourself, the animal is crowdfunded between a handful of customers. Shop by independent ranches handpicked for their practices and products, or choose a cut of beef , pork, chicken, lamb, or seafood.
There are also springtime and butchers specials, as well as craft meat gifts to send to the meat-lover in your life. Subscribe for free shipping and 5 percent off every order.
Recommended Reading: How Much Is A Steak Bagel At Mcdonalds
Best For Variety & Bragging Rights: Lobels Of New York
Lobels is one of the most famous names in meat, even outside the barbecue community. In fact, they may be better known among the very elite which frankly, totally excludes me. But, just because I dont hob-nob with Manhattan socialites , that doesnt mean I cant eat the same steaks!
Now into their sixth generation of family butchers, Lobels has a long and proud tradition of quality and a close connection with New York City. Case in point, you can enjoy a Lobels steak sandwich at Yankee Stadium.
Needless to say, there is a lot of cachet when you order steaks from Lobels, and youll want to name-drop as much as possible.
But, theres more to it than that, or I wouldnt have them on the list.
Lobels sells superior quality steaks and lots of them. Between the USDA Prime, Natural Prime, and American Wagyu categories, there are 56 steak cuts to choose from.
Many cuts are dry-aged for extra flavor, and some are cut double-thick for sharing, like the 30-ounce, 4-inch-thick double strip. Yum, times two!
Take lots of pictures, my friends! Theres no question that, for most of us, Lobels is not your everyday source for steaks. But, if youre a hardcore steak lover, its an experience you have to try, even if its only once.
You can discover the legend of Lobels of New York with a click right here:
Best For Specialty Beef: Snake River Farms
- Delivery Area: 50 states
-
Shipping not included
Snake River Farms produces specialty beef unlike the meat available from other farms and stores online. Company founders set out to create a farm with involvement in every step of the meat producing process, from how the cattle are raised to owning their own feedlots and processing facilities. As a part of this initiative, Snake River Farms bred its own type of cattle, American Wagyu, which produces beef with intense fat marbling, giving it a distinctive flavor.
Many cuts of steaks, roasts, and ribs are available along with ground meat, dry aged meat, and hot dogs. Most cuts and styles can be purchased individually, but there are also mixed boxes perfect for meal planning, parties, and gift-giving. All products are shipped frozen except for the dry-aged beef, which arrives fresh. There is no minimum order and shipping is not included. Standard shipping starts at $9.99 per order.
Read Also: How To Cook Medium Well Steak On Grill
Best Meat And Cheese Gift Baskets: Hickory Farms
When it comes to meat and cheese gift baskets, you can’t go wrong with Hickory Farms’ selection. You can shop its different meat and cheese categoriesâincluding beef summer sausage, keto gift baskets, and gluten-free optionsâto find an enjoyable gift for you or your loved ones. You can buy food baskets for almost any celebration and purchase special boxes like this Healthcare Heroes thank you delivery.
Hickory Farms’ meat and cheese gift baskets start at $18 and go up to $175. The Hearty Party gift box has over 1,200 five-star ratings from shoppers, with some reviewers saying “it has everything a family would want to enjoy for an afternoon snack” and “the perfect gift for many people on my Christmas list.” In this box, you get four sausages, seven gourmet cheeses, two mustards, and two boxes of crackers for $70. For Father’s Day and beyond, treat Dad to this $50 summer sausage and cheese box. It comes with summer sausage, three types of cheese, and two kinds of mustard.
Best For Gifts: Omaha Steaks
One of the nations first mail-order meat companies, Omaha Steaks has been slicing and sending specialty steaks across the country for more than a century. The brand is famous for its variety of cuts, like top-notch filet mignons, sirloins, ribeyes, and T-bones, but also has a wide selection of other meats, seafood, sides, dessert, and even wine. It also sells tons of gift packages across a range of price points. From under-$60 gift baskets filled with wine and cheese to a Butchers Share option that sends 95 pounds of Private Reserve beef in multiple shipments, theres something for everyone.
To buy: Starting at $10 omahasteaks.com
Read Also: Buy Philly Cheese Steak Meat
Read Also: What Is The Most Tender Steak
The #1 Online Steak Provider Is
After thoroughly reviewing well over a dozen steak providers, weve narrowed down ButcherBox as the best. They are great not just for steaks but also for other types of meat from ground bison to seafood.
Because they regularly deliver each month, you dont have to worry about constantly going to the grocery store. This, combined with their free delivery, also means you can save on restaurant costs using high-caliber hormone and steroid free meat.
You can select from different box options and can even customize your box based on your preferences. For high-caliber steaks regularly delivered to your door, check out ButcherBox.
#1 Meat Delivery Service
- Grass-fed and grass-finished beef delivered directly to your door
- Without antibiotics or added hormones
- Customizable boxes available
- Select from up to 21 different cuts
- Get the BEST PRICE until the end of
Q Why Are Mail Order Steaks So Expensive
A. Ordering from a meat delivery service online can be expensive. When ordering from a steak company online, youll usually get to select from a gourmet selection of beef. So one of the main reasons you may pay more is because of the high quality of the meat.
The prime cuts also need to be shipped carefully to preserve freshness as the order makes its way across the country. For this reason, your local family-owned butcher shop may be less expensive.
However, some meat delivery services like FarmFoods focuses on providing high-quality meat at an affordable price.
You May Like: Zwilling Twin Signature Steak Knives
Best Luxury: Snake River Farms Gold Grade Steaks
Snake River Farms
Steaks that have a higher fat content and marbling throughout offer a rich and buttery melt-in-your-mouth dining experience. Snake River Farms has an entire line of gold-grade American wagyu beef steaks that have been rated on the Japanese Beef Marbling Scale for superior fat marbling. Gold-grade steaks are available in top sirloin, filet mignon, New York strip, ribeye, flat iron, and entire roasts.
Snake River Farms’ thick-cut gold-grade Manhattan NY filet combines a New York strip steak with the special flavor of American wagyu beef. Reviewers say its full of juicy flavor and some even claim its the best steak theyve ever eaten, easily beating out high-end steakhouse dinners. Its available 6 or 8 ounces and in bulk shipments of 12, so you can stock up for yourself or seriously wow some lucky dinner guests.
