Our Pick: Messermeister Avanta Pakkawood Set
The Messermeister Avanta Pakkawood steak knife set was our clear winner. No other knives came close to matching their combination of performance, price, and quality of construction. Their blade-edges are well-formed, smooth, and extremely sharp they cut even the toughest steaks as well as knives we tested that cost five times as much, which cant be said for most others in their price range. Their handles are finished with pakkawood, a durable resin-impregnated natural wood usually only found on more expensive knives. And unlike any other knives we found at the price, they feature full-tang construction: A single piece of steel forms the blade, bolsters, and handle. This adds strength , balance, and heft. The latter is an aesthetic concern, but an important one: 2015’s test revealed that a knife weight of around 80 grams feels just right in the hand. The Messermeisters weigh 89 gramspleasantly robust, and significantly nicer to hold than the lightweight knives typical at this price.
No other knives came close to matching their combination of performance, price, and quality of construction.
Also unique to the Messermeisters price range, their handles are finished with pakkawoodan industry term for resin-impregnated natural woodinstead of the more-common cheap plastic or unfinished wood. Pakkawood is strong, durable, and stablebasically, it doesnt absorb water or dry out and expand or shrink accordinglybut retains the rich and variegated look of natural wood.
What To Look For In A Steak Knife
- Exclusive Double-D® edgeThe Double-D® edge has three distinct cutting edges that cut food whether you are moving forward, backward or straight down. It provides a clean, smooth cut every time and stays sharper longer than straight-edge knives. Can be factory sharpened.
- Ergonomic handleUniversal fit for large or small, left or right hands. Thumb and forefinger lock into place for safety and control. Fatigue-resistant design.
- Full tangProvides strength and balance with the blade extending the full length of the handle. The triple rivet construction securely attaches the handle to the blade and the nickel silver rivets will resist pitting and tarnishing. Rivets are also flush with the handle for comfort and durability.
How Does It Cut Steak
But lets talk about how effective it is at doing what its meant to do. For cutting steak, its really great thanks to the serration. A bonus point is earned for the fact that sharpening wont be needed with these Cutco knives. You may not be the type of person who would particularly enjoy the process of sharpening a blade, and in that case, this Cutco set is ideal. But otherwise, if you look forward to giving your knife a good run on the whetstone, we advise that you go for a smooth-bladed collection. While they can be impressively sharp, non-serrated knives require frequent maintenance over time, while sharpening serrated knives at home is difficult task.
Weve kind of brushed through the toughness and the warranty of the knife a minute ago, but its actually something that deserves a spotlight. Youll have to try it to understand the meaning of having a 440A blade. This is one of the best stainless-steel grades that you can have for a knife. Whats great about it is that it ensures a sustainable sharpness for the blades edge. Having one of these knives can mean that you wont have to buy another one for decades because of how it can stand the test of time.
Recommended Reading: Steak Eze Sams
What Cutco Customers Are Saying
Since Cutco knives were traditionally sold door-to-door, some chefs are quick to overlook this product however, Cutco customers are usually pleased with their knives. The blades tend to hold their sharpness, and since the company offers such a good warranty and free sharpening for the life of the knife, there seems to be little risk in purchasing these knives.
Although the average consumer may not be knowledgeable about knife production, experts say that Cutco knives are inferior because they are stamped instead of forged. Stamped knives are cut from a sheet of steel instead of being manufactured from a single piece of steel. Stamped knives are less costly to produce and are not as durable, sharp, and substantial-feeling as a forged knife.
Experts also question the quality of the 440A stainless steel that Cutco uses to manufacture its blades. Other knife companies that are at the same price point as Cutco use 440C steel. In general, 440A steel is usually used in cheaper knives.
Now that you know a bit more about Cutco, lets take a look at one of their biggest competitors, Wusthof.
Budget Pick: Chicago Cutlerys Walnut Tradition Set
*At the time of publishing, the price was $30.
Chicago Cutlerys Walnut Tradition steak knife set is the best low-cost set out there. The knives are not perfect by any metric: the blade-edges are coarse and uneven at 60 grams/2 ounces, theyre a bit lighter than wed like and the fit-and-finish is indifferent. In fact, they appear just to be industrial-grade boning knives with steak knife handles slapped on. Put it this way: if the Messermeisters give you more than you pay for aesthetically, these give you exactly what you pay for, and not a penny more.
They work far better than the serrated blades you usually have to settle for at this price.
But theyre built to last and they work perfectly welland, more importantly, they work far better than the serrated blades you usually have to settle for at this price. Theyre a great choice for outfitting a crowd, taking along on country picnics, or while car camping. Not fancy, perfectly functional, and if you lose one, youll shed no tears.
Also Check: Omaha Steaks Delivery Tracking
Best Cutco Knives Alternative My Suggestion
Cutco knives are really not for everyone and I can say that there are better alternatives that are either for the same price or even cheaper. If you really like Cutco than go for it, there is nothing wrong about their products except higher price tag, but if you are looking for the best deal and highest quality/price ratio I would go for Wüsthof Gourmet Twelve Piece Block Set.
This set contains 1/2 Paring Knife, 3 Spear Point Paring Knife, 4 1/2 Utility Knife, Four 4 1/2 Steak Knives, 8 Bread Knife, 8 Cooks Knife, 9 Steel, Come-Apart Kitchen Shears and a 13-Slot Block. Wüsthof is known brand for high quality knives that are not overpriced and if you will not do anything really stupid with them and you do not look for anything special, these will be the only knives you need for everyday use in your kitchen. You do not need to buy several different products, but you get all the basic knives for everyday use in your kitchen and this is of course much cheaper than buying them separately.
If you prefer American-made knives than I can absolutely recommend Rada Cutlery. Their knives are high quality for much lower price than Cutco. What I do not like much about Rada are the handles, but if you are not someone who has knife in hand for many hours every day, like chefs in restaurants do, than I think it will not be a problem for you.
What Wusthofs Customers Are Saying
Wusthof customers love their knives, as evident by their . The company has a long track record of customer satisfaction. Although their warranty is not as forgiving as Cutcos, under typical use, there is hardly ever a need for a replacement.
Wusthof customers rarely complain, but those that do usually have unrealistic expectations based on the premium price they paid. The interesting thing about these complaints is that Wusthofs prices are typical for high quality forged knives and are right in line with Zwilling, Shun, and even Cutco, whose knives are not forged.
Anyone complaining that Wusthofs knives are too expensive should opt for one of their cheaper lines, like the Gourmet or Pro, or buy lower quality brands altogether.
Read Also: Larry’s Steaks Menu Rising Sun
One Stop Shop To Buy Cutco Products Online In Mumbai Delhi Bangalore Hyderabad Ahmedabad Chennai Kolkata Surat Pune Jaipur & All Major Cities
If you are looking for all the best international brands and genuine quality global products, your search ends here. Most people would love to find all their essential products in one location, whenever they choose to buy anything. Hence, it is very essential and beneficial to find a genuine, reliable and trustworthy online store to buy Cutco products. A good online store is a quintessential stop to discover a galaxy of brands and products to suit every requirement. If you are looking for exclusive Cutco products online in Mumbai, Delhi, Bangalore, Hyderabad, Ahmedabad, Chennai, Kolkata, Surat, Pune, Jaipur, etc you can find it effortlessly on Ubuy which is a one-stop-shop to explore from over 100 million products and brands from international market. It is also the right place to find products that are not easily available elsewhere.
To find a perfect collection of unique and popular global products from Cutco, Ubuy online shopping can help you to get the right product that suits your specific requirements. You can discover the latest offers on Cutco products and save money each time you decide to purchase. Searching for your preferred products and brands across towns and cities may not be necessary for this modern technological era since your products are just one click away. So, get ready to find and buy all your desirable products from your best-loved brands on Ubuy.
Upgrade Pick: Wsthof Classic Ikon Set
*At the time of publishing, the price was $300.
Our testers all favored the Ikon’s classic understated elegance.
The Wüsthof Classic Ikon steak knives arent cheap, but they are the cheapest of the three high-end sets that we tested. With little to distinguish between the high-end sets on performancewhich was universally exceptionalaesthetics played the largest role in this pick, and our testers all favored the Ikon’s classic, understated elegance. Their razor-sharp blades have the ideal upswept shape. The unique double-concave curves of their satiny black POM handles fit the hand wonderfully both our smallest and our largest tester found them the most comfortable to hold of all the knives we tested. Their full-tang construction adds strength and, at 77 grams/2.6 ounces, pleasing heft. Lastly, their construction is flawlessas it should be for the price. Because in truth, its the flawless fit-and-finish, more than anything else, that separates an exceptional luxury steak knife from a really great mid-priced oneand that you pay for.
One criticism: the Ikons come in a simple, clear plastic box. Its sturdy enough to use for knife storage but left us wishing for something more distinguished-looking, particularly if the knives are intended to be a gift. For about $100 more, the blackwood-handled Ikon steak knives come in a walnut case its unfortunate that this is not an option for the standard model.
Don’t Miss: Pee Dee Steak House On 125
Similarities Between Cutco And Wusthof
Cutco and Wusthof have been perfecting the craft of knife making for decades and share many similarities. The following are the most notable similarities:
Performance: Both companies produce high-performing knives that are durable and last a lifetime.
History: Both companies have stood the test of time. Wusthof has 200 years under its belt, and Cutco has been making knives for almost 75 years.
Ergonomic Handles: Both Cutco and Wusthof offer ergonomically-designed handles made from a variety of materials.
Sharpening: Both companies offer a mail-order sharpening program at a minimal cost.
Caring and Cleaning: Both companies recommend that consumers hand wash and dry their products to keep them in tip-top shape.
Customizable: You can personalize Cutco and Wusthof knives by engraving or monogramming the blades.
Price: Even though there are many different levels of Wusthof knives, on average, Cutco and Wusthof are priced similarly. Check their current prices on Amazon .
Best Knife Set On A Budget Victorinox Swiss Army Cutlery Swiss Classic Knife Block Set 22
Victorinox has been making knives since 1884 and theyre a trusted brand by many chefs around the globe. Im a huge fan of Victorinox because I think they make great quality knives for a very fair price.
I love their simple and minimalist design and comfortable grips. My personal favourite is their 4inch serrated utily knife thats perfect for cutting tomatoes, light vegetables are even carving pumpkins.
Although for serious home cooks looking for a bit more quality, these knives may feel a little cheap.
Just like Cutco, the Rockwell scale on these knives is around 56 and will need to be sharpened and honed more than knives from Wusthof or Henkels.
But considering the price, I think these knives are a steal .
At less than half of what you would pay for the Cutco 19pc set, this 22 pc set even comes with 3 extra knives. Bonus!
Also Check: Seasoning Steak Overnight
Notes On Materials And Construction
If youve spent more than a few minutes researching knives, youve likely run into a bewildering fog of jargon and technical specifications. Heres a quick guide, which applies to steak knives, chefs knives, and everything in between:
The phrase high-carbon steel is basically marketing hype: every steel alloy used to make knives is high-carbon. You can ignore the phrase it if its used, and you neednt worry if its not. Do note, however, that if a knife is listed only as high-carbon or carbon steel, it will easily rust. To be sure your knife is rust-resistant, make sure it is also listed as stainless.
Stainless steel is steel alloyed with at least 12 percent, and usually 14 to 18 percent, chromium. The chromium forms a dense layer on any exposed surface which rapidly oxidizes, preventing oxidation of the steel underneath. There are multiple types of stainless steel, some more corrosion-resistant than others all those used on our recommended knives are high-performing: extremely corrosion-resistant, capable of taking and holding a sharp edge and easy to re-sharpen.
There are thousands of different steel alloysmixtures of iron, carbon, and any of 20 or more other elementseach designed for a different purpose. Knife alloys alone run into the dozens, and the names are alphabet soup: AEB-L, VG-10, 19C27, ZDP-189. My advice is: ignore them all, at least for steak knives. Whatever alloy a good manufacturer chooses will perform perfectly well.
What About The Steel In A Cutco Knife Set
So Cutco has a bit of a shaky past, but are their knives any good?
Short answer: Not really.
Cutco makes all of their knives with a stamped 440 A steel which is relatively low-quality steel and nothing to get excited about.
While Wusthof and Victorinox both use a much higher quality chromium-molybdenum-vanadium steel in their high-end knives.
Zwilling also uses high-carbon German stainless steel in its base-level knives.
All of these knives use similar to better quality steel in their knives with much cheaper prices than Cutco.
Don’t Miss: Pee Dee Steak House On 125 Menu
Whats The Deal With Stamped And Forged Knives
Generally speaking, forged knives are superior to stamped knives.
Cutco knives are made using stamped steel which means theyre cheaper to produce.
Although theres nothing wrong with stamped knives, they dont always hold their edge as long as forged knives.
To put this in perspective, Henckels has mostly stamped knives and Wusthof is almost always made of forged steel.
That means that youll have to sharpen stamped knives sooner than forged knives.
Also, unlike other popular knife brands, Cutco doesnt offer a higher grade steel or premium knife set so anyone looking for higher-quality steel is out of luck.
Most Comfortable: Cutco Steak 4
Cutco knives have a loyal following, and for good reason: The company offers a lifetime guarantee on its knives and offers free lifetime sharpening services . When it comes to serrated knives, which can’t be sharpened with most traditional sharpeners, this is a great amenity.
The Cutco steak knives have a high-quality construction, with the resin handles riveted seamlessly onto the full-tang blades, and special, serrated edges that are designed so there’s a cutting surface in every direction, whether the knife is moving forwards, backwards, or straight down.
While they do tear the meat a little more than some of the other blades on this list, they do work well even on gristly pieces of meat, with just a little pressure and effort. These are some of the most comfortable knives we’ve tried: The polished resin handles have a unique shape that fits perfectly in the hand, wider in the middle with indentations at the thumb and pinky. It almost feels like they’ve been molded to fit the grip, and seems like it would be comfortable for both small and large hands.
Buy It: $296 cutco.com
Don’t Miss: Mcdonald’s Steak Egg And Cheese Bagel Nutrition
Best For Entertaining: Dubost Laguiole Natura Steak Knives Set Of 6
These ornate steak knives look like an heirloom passed down from Grandmaand maybe they will be one day. They have a classic, old-school design, with a gracefully curved handle made of polished plastic that has a slightly swirly, pearlized finish. The set includes three each of the two handle colors: Chocolate and Fudge . Adorned with the French cutlery maker’s iconic bee on top of the bolster where the blade meets the handle, these knives have an eclectic look that will dress up any dinner table.
As for their performance, the knife blades have a unique construction of tiny serration interspersed with larger cutout hollows. The hollows prevent juicy steaks from clinging to the blade, and the tiny serration created less tearing and drag than some of the longer-toothed blades we tried. The knives are very lightweight and had decent balance, and the handles were comfortable to hold, with the curve fitting nicely into the pinky-finger end of the hand. However, these delicate, narrow knives might be difficult to use for someone with larger hands.
The French brand Dubost Laguiole has stood the test of time it’s 100 years old and is a leader in the plastic-handled cutlery category.
Buy It: $100 williams-sonoma.com