Butcherbox Vs Omaha Steaks: Customer Support & Service
I’ve had only positive experiences with the customer service with both delivery services. Both have online customer service representatives that respond in time, on their site, or via phone call. But, because the Butcher Box focuses on clean meat, they have been better at answering my past questions.
As a carnivore diet follower, my focus is specific. I want to find the highest quality and cleanest meat I can get that is cost-effective. The Butcher Box service is more in line with most people’s needs than Omaha Steaks.
Key Difference Between Kansas City Steaks & Omaha Steaks
The main difference between the two delivery services is in their sourcing practices.
Kansas City Steaks sources 100% grass-fed beef for steaks, while Omaha Steaks finishes their cattle on grain for years.
Kansas City Steaks also appears to have USDA Prime, while its competitor labels their meat cut deals as agency-inspected.
Both serve other items such as pork, ham, seafood, plus free-range chicken.
They sure seem to have more game options, including bison and veal cut.
We had even heard rumors that Kansas City steaks were expensive. Still, when we tried out some popular ribeyes and American-style filet mignons a day ago, Omaha’s deals ended up being more costly in the cart, and it’s something that we’re not used to.
Omaha Steaks
- 100% organic, free-range
Are Omaha Steaks Supposed To Arrive Frozen
Are the packages in which Omaha Steaks products arrive cold and will you please specify how it will arrive frozen? All of Omaha Steaks packages arrive frozen in our Mini Deep Freeze packaging for a fast shipping process. Several bags of dry ice are used in our polystyrene insulated cooler. This packaging combination can handle any kind of environment.
Recommended Reading: Wusthof 6 Piece Steak Knife Set
Chicago Steak Or Omaha Steaks We Choose
Based on our Chicago Steaks Vs Omaha Steaks comparison, while both companies claim to have the best steak, we think that Chicago Steak Company offers a better deal when it comes to the menu options and prices. They offer a wider list of beef that includes dry-aged steak.
But if you ask us, we recommend ButcherBox for our meats shipped week after week. We are quite impressed with how we always get the same great cut plus the best buttery taste every time we make an order.
You also get to curate your own subscription and have it delivered right to your doorstep, free of charge.
#1 Meat Delivery Service
- Grass-fed and grass-finished beef delivered directly to your door
- Without antibiotics or added hormones
- Customizable boxes available
- Select from up to 21 different cuts
- Get the BEST PRICE until the end of
Comparing Omaha Steak & Butcherbox Selection
At first glance, it would seem that Omaha Steaks is the winner when it comes to meat in a box option and different small or big cuts. Indeed they have plenty more to choose from.
Upon closer inspection, I found that the products of Omaha Steaks werent always a good option for the carnivore diet. Many of the meats that Omaha Steaks sells are pre-seasoned and come with non-carnivore diet sides.
The options include chicken, beef, and pork. You may save time in seasoning before cooking, but even small condiments are not recommended for carnivore dieters.
With ButcherBox, you are getting the best grass-fed and grass-finished beef, heritage breed pork, and free-range organic chicken strictly. Every meat they use is no doubt hand-picked and of good quality. Its no-nonsense, and I also dont have to worry about their meats messing with my diet.
You May Like: Bacon Wrapped Filet Omaha Steaks
News Result For What Grade Is Omaha Steaks
The best meat delivery in 2021: Snake River Farms, Omaha Steaks, Rastellis and moreYour browser indicates if youve visited this link
CNET
gradeSteakOmahaSteaks
Invited to a holiday party this year? Dont forget to bring one of these great host giftsYour browser indicates if youve visited this link
WTVO
This ultra-popular steak chain will now ship meat right to your doorYour browser indicates if youve visited this link
SteakSteakOmahaSteaks
The 60 Best Christmas Gifts for Dad to Unwrap This Holiday SeasonYour browser indicates if youve visited this link
Mens Health
OmahaSteakssteakgrade
South Sides Diallo Riddle Talks Up Season 2s Gems, Explains Why His Curb Your Enthusiasm Turn Fell FlatYour browser indicates if youve visited this link
Yahoo News
GradeOmahaSteaks
Script to Screen Announces Webinar on Top Influencer Marketing Strategies for 2022Your browser indicates if youve visited this link
Yahoo
Iowa Farmers Work Toward a Diverse FutureYour browser indicates if youve visited this link
dtnpf.com
Omaha Steaks Vs Butcherbox
CONTENTSTimothy Woods
Both Butcher Box and Omaha Steaks are well recognized for their high quality meat and great meal delivery services.
However, many people claim that the two have some subtle differences that make one slightly more advantageous than the other.
We decided to put this claim to the test, and after many hours of research and three-month-long testing, weve gathered a few interesting facts for you.
Lets discuss both Butcher Box and Omaha Steaks below.
Read Also: Best Frozen Steak For Cheesesteak
How Are Omaha Steaks Aged
The majority of their steak is dry-aged for around 20 days, in a temperature and humidity controlled environment. Wet aging is more economical, as it takes mere days. With dry aging, the process takes longer. Wet aging vs dry aging is not as simple as one being superior to the other it depends on the cut of meat. Dry aging is preferred for meat with more fat and marbling, while wet aging is suited for lean cuts, such as flank or flat iron steak.
Whats So Special About Omaha Steaks
Omaha Steaks is perhaps the oldest mail-order steak company, but it didnt start as a delivery company. Omaha Steaks was founded in 1917 in Omaha, Nebraska, where it is still headquartered today. What was at the time a local butcher shop expanded into a mail order service in the early 1950s. By 1960, Omaha Steaks expanded its outreach by introducing vacuum-sealed packaging and dry ice to help the meat stay fresh for longer. A famous highlight was in 1961 when President John F Kennedy enjoyed Omaha Steaks. That year Omaha Steaks also earned acclaim at the Culinary Olympics in Germany.
Thus, Omaha Steaks established a glowing image of tender meat, customer service, and convenience. The question is: has that reputation held up, especially amidst competitors?
Recommended Reading: Montreal Steak Seasoning Ingredients Mccormick
Don’t Miss: Omaha Steaks Wine Gift Baskets
What Comes In A Butcher Box:
ButcherBox has a lot of options for what comes in their boxes. Here are some of the options that you can select
- Beef: Stew Beef, Sirloin Tips, Ground Beef, Trip Tip, Burgers, Flat Iron Steaks, Beef Briskey, Bottom Round Roast, Shoulder Roast, Sirloin Cap, Eye of Round Roast, Ranch Steaks, NY Strip Steaks
- Chicken: Whole Chicken, Boneless Skinless Breasts, Chicken Tenders, Boneless or Bone-In Chicken Thighs, Ground Chicken, Drumsticks, Chicken Wings
- Pork: Ground Pork, Breakfast Sausage, Center Cut Pork Loin Roast, Boneless Pork Chops, Pork Sirloin Roasts, Bone in Pork Butt, Bacon, Pork Tenderloin
- Seafood: Salmon, Salmon Burgers, Cod
- Other: Ground Turkey, Ground Bison, Uncured Hot Dogs
When you join ButcherBox right now you can get 1 pack of bacon for free and $20 off your first box!
How Do You Select The Best Meat Online
Selecting the best meat online is tricky. Unlike shopping at a butchers or a grocery store, you cant inspect the meat yourself. The best beef, for instance, has a reddish color and even abundant marbling but is balanced so as not to be fatty. Theres also a different smell between fresh and older meat. So, ordering online takes a small leap of faith. Yet, it isnt a blind chance. Here are some factors I also consider when looking for meat online:
Don’t Miss: Tools Of The Trade Steak Knives
Omaha Steaks Review: How Good Is This Mail Order Steak Company
Bottom Line
Omaha Steaks has a huge variety of delicious food but they lack transparency when it comes to their meat quality, USDA grading, and sourcing practices.
Pros
They offer a huge amount of variety, making it a good choice for big parties.
Their premade options are delicious .
It could make for a good gift.
Cons
The pricing can be confusing and annoying.
They lack transparency when it comes to meat quality, USDA grading, and sourcing.
Their packaging is all styrofoam and plasticnot environmentally friendly at all.
Not Sure What Box Is Right For You?
No need to spend hours searching. and Iâll send you my personal favorites !
Over the years weve reviewed dozens of different meat delivery boxes but none of them are as well-known as Omaha Steaks.
Chances are youve either received Omaha Steaks as a gift, youve given it as a gift, or youve at least seen their ads. This is because theyre one of the oldest meat delivery services out there. But does that make them the best?
Today were unboxing, taste testing, and reviewing Omaha Steaks to find out if one of the oldest meat delivery services is really worth it.
Jump To A Section
View this post on Instagram
The story of Omaha Steaks starts, not in the United States, but rather in Latvia.
Due to immense popularity in the town, the company began growing and in 1952 they became one of the first butchers to advertise mail order steaks in magazines.
Comparing The Menu Options
Both companies have similar nice classic beef and quality meats, such as New York strip steak, filet mignon, ribeyes, top sirloin, prime rib, and a T-bone with really tasty flavor.
They both also offer high-grade seafood, free-range chicken, turkey, and Berkshire pork for meat delivery.
We love how they both offer exclusive Black Angus all year long, as well.
We say that’s one good meal you would want to try and share with your family or give as a gift to close friends.
For your party, you can add wine, a variety of country dish sides, and everything’s perfect.
For the purpose of ourOmaha Steaks review, we found out that the business may have a more extensive menu that you can place an order on. They offer bison, veal, wet-aged beef, and gourmet burgers for you to cook.
Read Also: Quaker Steak And Lube Gift Card
Do Omaha Steaks Have Hormones
Steaks has everything from a basket of live lobsters to a Fourth of July ready feast complete with burgers, sausages and delicious seasoning. All of the meat is hormone-free, antibiotic-free, pasture-raised and comes from kentucky and northern kentucky farms.
Bar is a family-owned and operated steakhouse and oyster bar located in the heart of downtown Omaha, Nebraska. The restaurant offers a wide variety of steaks and seafood, as well as a full bar and live music on the weekends. They also have a great selection of beer, wine, and cocktails.
Omaha Steaks Got In Trouble For Violating Telemarketing Laws
Perhaps you’ve gotten a call or two from a robocaller at Omaha Steaks trying to sell us on their holiday gift box special that’s stuffed to the brim with gourmet hamburgers and tri-tips galore. Well, in 2014, one man in Gresham, Oregon, had received just one call too many, as The Oregonian reported.
According to The Oregonian, Michael Hetherington received 10 unwarranted calls to his cell phone from the company over the course of just a little over a month in 2013. Hetherington did some research on laws surrounding telemarketing and realized that the company could be breaching the Telephone Consumer Protection Act of 1991. The act essentially states that companies aren’t allowed to call customers without their permission nor can they use automated programs to dial up random numbers with added emphasis in regards to protecting cell phone numbers. This is exactly what Omaha Steaks was doing when they called Hetherington those 10 times and he filed a lawsuit against them in 2014.
The lawsuit grew into a wider class action suit and was eventually settled about two years later in 2016, when the company had to shell out $5 million to customers they’d called in violation of the TCPA. According to Top Class Actions, a website investigating various class action suits across the country, customers began receiving checks from Omaha Steaks for around $40 in December 2016.
You May Like: How Long To Grill Tri Tip Steak
Is It Cheaper To Buy Meat Online
Generally the meat you find from online butchers caters to the high end of the market.
This makes sense, people looking to order steak online are looking for a way to get their hands on the best quality grass-fed, Wagyu or sustainable raised beef. Not save money.
Having said that, some of the companies in our guide are cheaper than others, so its definitely worth shopping around.
Wrapping it up
You now have no excuses for wasting money on cheap steak from the supermarket.
If you dont have any good butcher shops near you dont despair. We truly live in a golden age for meat lovers with the best butchers delivering amazing quality steak to your door.
You might also want to check out our guide on where to buy Wagyu Beef online.
If youve never ordered steak online before you should definitely give it a try. Its a safe and convenient way to try steak that could previously only be tasted in the finest restaurants.
Not sure what steak to order? Check out our guide to the best steak for grilling.
How To Order Omaha Steaks
Ordering Omaha Steaks is simple. While you can call 1-800-960-8400, itâs far easier to fill up your online shopping cart on the website, where nearly every single page shows you mouth-watering meats so you know what youâre getting. Shipping is free on any order of $149 and up, but thatâs not a hard number to hit when youâre filling your cart with premium steaks.
While subscription plans are available in monthly, bi-monthly, or quarterly options, you can also order a one-off box, and Omaha Steaks will even let you assemble your own custom combinations.
You can also order gift cards and plans, but fair warning that many people on TripAdvisor who arenât regular Omaha Steaks customers found themselves frustrated by the companyâs tendency to list meats at one price as part of a larger box or a much more expensive one if ordered alone. Add in the shipping threshold and you may find gift cards an aggravating present to your loved ones during the holidays.
Recommended Reading: Fast Fixin Chicken Fried Steak
Dry Ice Plays A Key Role With Omaha Steaks
Ever wonder how Omaha Steaks manages to keep their products fresh, even while they’re shipping them all the way across the country? As Dr. Youling Xiong wrote in Lawrie’s Meat Science, “Raw meat is one of the most shelf-unstable food materials due to its abundance in nutrients ideally suited for microorganisms.” This means that transporting uncooked steak products from state to state takes a lot of care.
When the company began its mail-order operations in 1952, they settled on using wax-lined cartons filled with dry ice to keep the meat cool essentially mimicking a refrigerator. As polystyrene and vacuum packaging became more popular and mainstream, Omaha Steaks ditched the wax-lined containers and began using those, in conjunction with dry ice as the means of keeping the meat cool.
Vacuum packaging, combined with the dry ice, ensures that the meat has no exposure to air and thus, bacteria while the dry ice keeps the temperature down low without requiring any electricity.
Dont Just Take It From Us
See what our customers are saying
The meat is sourced from a variety of farms and, boy, does the quality show. NO comparison to store-bought meat! Katherine H. from OregonThe greatest quality grass-fed beef at cheaper prices than my farmers market. Shiaun T. from CaliforniaI work in London and Paris and and was a cook in another life! These are some of the most wonderful lamb chops we have had ever!!! Thank you! David S. From MassachusettsI tried ButcherBox. The service, meat quality, and value did not meet my expectations after experiencing Crowd Cow. Christina Q. of Kansas
Also Check: The Best Steak Cuts To Eat
Best Mail Order Steaks In 2022
SmokedBBQSource is supported by its readers. We may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you if you buy through a link on this page. Learn more.
Until recently if you wanted to buy the best quality steak you were severely limited by where you lived.
Luckily we are now spoilt for choice, with a range of specialty butcher shops delivering restaurant-quality steak online.
Even if you live in a small city, these online butchers deliver steak to your door anywhere in the continental United States.
Weve rounded up the best mail order steak companies in the country for buying steak online.
You May Like: Pork Chops On The Grill How Long To Cook
Is Omaha Steak Frozen
Omaha Steaks single-ingredient chicken is born, grown, and harvested entirely within the United States of America . Upon completion of a rigorous set of quality inspections and under the supervision of the United States Department of Agriculture, these items are processed at factories in the United States.
Also Check: Victorinox Rosewood Steak Knife Set
Which Has A Better Meat Selection
At first glance, it would seem that Omaha Steaks is the winner when it comes to meat in a box option and different small or big cuts. Indeed they have plenty more to choose from.
Upon closer inspection, I found that Omaha Steaks wasn’t always a good option for the carnivore diet. Many of the premium meats this meat delivery service sells are pre-seasoned and come with non-carnivore diet sides.
The Omaha Steaks options include chicken, beef, and pork. You may save time in seasoning before cooking, but even small condiments are not recommended for carnivore dieters.
With Butcher Box, you get the best grass-fed beef, heritage breed pork, and free-range organic chicken. Every flavorful meat Omaha Steaks uses is no doubt hand-picked and of good quality. It’s no-nonsense, and I also don’t have to worry about their meats messing with my diet.
