Chicago Cutlery Reviews: What Do Customers Think
Customers rave about Chicago Cutlerys crafted knives. The positive reviews cite their excellent quality and affordable prices.
Many also praise their sleek designs, with very few products ranking below 4/5 stars. For example, the Insignia 18-piece set has an average of 4.9/5 stars based on 20 ratings.
One customer gushed about the knife set, writing, These knives have a beautiful, glossy stainless steel finish If you want a QUALITY knife set, I HIGHLY recommend that you purchase this knife set, for you will NOT regret buying this knife set.
Its safe to say that Chicago Cutlery is loved by many. Another customer talks about the outstanding durability of the Walnut Tradition Steak Knives, saying, This is my second set of knives. I bought the others 37 years ago.
They continue to say that the steak knives are easy to handle for arthritic hands. Now thats dependability and accessibility that this Chicago Cutlery knife set review can appreciate.
The brands other products are rated highly on their official website:
- Insignia2 18-piece Block Set: 4.9/5 stars out of nearly 100 ratings
- Walnut Tradition 4-piece Steak Knife Set: 4.8/5 stars out of over 60 ratings
- Walnut Tradition 10 Bread Knife / Slicer: 4.9/5 stars out of 30 ratings
- Deluxe Scissors: 4.9/5 stars out of 50+ ratings
The Insignia2 set averages about 4.7/5 stars based on a whopping 860 ratings on Amazon.
Best Overall Knife Set: Chicago Cutlery Fusion 17
First things first: Of the 11 knife sets we tested, this was one of the cheapest. At $129.99, you might reasonably expect theyd be lower quality than their more expensive counterparts. Youd be wrong. We were blown away by the sturdy construction, comfort of use and reliable execution that came with each piece in this all-inclusive set. True, there were sharper, higher-quality knives in several of the other sets we tested, but when it came to overall rankings, performance and consideration of cost, the Chicago Cutlery Fusion 17-Piece Knife Block Set was the clear champion.
One big plus: the whopping 17 included pieces. Besides the classic and heavy chestnut-stained wood block, you get a 7 3/4-inch chefs knife, 7 3/4-inch serrated bread knife, 7-inch santoku knife, 5-inch santoku knife, 5-inch utility knife, 3 1/4-inch paring knife and eight yes, eight! 4 1/2-inch steak knives, plus a sharpening steel and chop assist. The only thing missing is kitchen shears, but you can add a pair like these OXO Good Grips Multipurpose Kitchen Scissors to your utensil drawer later.
Also putting Chicago over the top were all the extras: The steak knives performed great while slicing through grilled filet mignon and the two santoku knives were handy for slicing cheese, mincing garlic and scooping everything off the cutting board.
Other Kitchen Knife Sets We Tested
Shun Classic 6-piece Slim Knife Block Set
Theres no denying it: These are the sharpest knives we have ever used. Handcrafted in Seki, Japan, the durable, beautiful and razor-sharp Damascus stainless steel blades had us oohing and aahing at their ability to perfectly slice through everything. The paring knife, for instance, was so sharp that as we used it to core a tomato, we found it was shaving skin off our finger from the slightest touch. We also swooned over how the knives felt in our hands the pakkawood handles were heavy, but the knives remained well-balanced. So, why was this not among our winners? The pricey set comes with just three knives: an 8-inch chefs knife, 3 1/2-inch paring knife and 7-inch santoku knife. It also includes a slim dark wood knife block, which we liked, but the included honing steel and shears felt like afterthought additions. If youre looking for pure sharpness? Hands down, Shun is the winner.
Calphalon Classic Self-Sharpening Stainless Steel 15-piece Knife Block Set
Cuisinart C77SS 15-Piece Stainless Steel Hollow Handle Block Set
AmazonBasics Premium 18-Piece Kitchen Knife Block Set
Dalstrong 5-Piece Shadow Series Knife Block Set
Vremi 10-Piece Colorful Knife Set
Mercer Culinary Genesis 6-Piece Forged Knife Block Set
J.A. Henckels International 15-Piece Statement Knife Block Set
Read more from CNN Underscoreds hands-on testing:
Don’t Miss: Mcdonalds Steak Egg And Cheese Bagel Calories
Pros And Cons Of Chicago Cutlery Knives
When deciding to buy a new set of knives, many people are drawn to the sleek design and reputation of Chicago Cutlery. However, before making a purchase, it is important to be aware of both the pros and cons of this popular brand.
– Chicago Cutlery knives are made from high-carbon stainless steel, which makes them extremely sharp and resistant to rusting or staining.
– The blades are also heat-treated for additional strength and durability.
– The handles are ergonomically designed for comfort and easy grip, even when wet.
– Knives in the Chicago Cutlery Fusion line come with a lifetime warranty.
– Many users find that the blades require frequent sharpening.
– Others have complained that the knives are not as durable as they would like, and the handles have been known to loosen or break with extended use.
– Chicago Cutlery knives can be more expensive than other brands on the market.
In my opinion, the pros of Chicago Cutlery knives outweigh the cons. The fact that they are made from high-quality materials and come with a lifetime warranty makes them worth the investment. However, it is important to keep in mind that these knives will require more care than some other brands. If you are looking for a durable, affordable option, you may want to consider another brand.
Notes On Materials And Construction
If youve spent more than a few minutes researching knives, youve likely run into a bewildering fog of jargon and technical specifications. Heres a quick guide, which applies to steak knives, chefs knives, and everything in between:
The phrase high-carbon steel is basically marketing hype: every steel alloy used to make knives is high-carbon. You can ignore the phrase it if its used, and you neednt worry if its not. Do note, however, that if a knife is listed only as high-carbon or carbon steel, it will easily rust. To be sure your knife is rust-resistant, make sure it is also listed as stainless.
Stainless steel is steel alloyed with at least 12 percent, and usually 14 to 18 percent, chromium. The chromium forms a dense layer on any exposed surface which rapidly oxidizes, preventing oxidation of the steel underneath. There are multiple types of stainless steel, some more corrosion-resistant than others all those used on our recommended knives are high-performing: extremely corrosion-resistant, capable of taking and holding a sharp edge and easy to re-sharpen.
There are thousands of different steel alloysmixtures of iron, carbon, and any of 20 or more other elementseach designed for a different purpose. Knife alloys alone run into the dozens, and the names are alphabet soup: AEB-L, VG-10, 19C27, ZDP-189. My advice is: ignore them all, at least for steak knives. Whatever alloy a good manufacturer chooses will perform perfectly well.
Read Also: Steak Eze Sams
Overview Of Chicago Cutlery
Founded by Alfred Paulson in 1930, Chicago Cutlery is committed to delivering quality crafted products. They have roots in 20th century Chicago where the brand originally started as a knife sharpening service for butchers.
Chicago Cutlery expanded from knife sharpening in the 1940s and began to manufacture and rent products. Over the years, their clientele spread across the United States and internationally, and Paulsons brand grew to become the #1 brand in forged cutlery.
Today, the brand continues to create inexpensive kitchen staples from the Corelle brand headquarters in Greencastle, Pennsylvania. Before we get into our Chicago Cutlery knife set review, lets talk about a few pros and cons of the brand:
Knife Sets Are Attractive
And that is not a bad place to be, as, while you can easily purchase individual knives, buying a knife set can save you a ton of dough. Knife sets are attractive to people because of all of the perceived value in a knife set. And some of that value may even add up, as buying three quality knives, in some cases, costs more than buying a complete set of knives.
Also, you get a knife block out of the deal. And the deal gets even sweeter when the block comes with sharpeners. Many manufacturers of knife set are realizing what a strong draw a real wood knife block can have. Chicago Cutlery even offers a cherry block on one of their sets, as listed above
In our opinion, though, if you do opt for a knife set, try to weed out the set overwrought with meaningless pieces. A good quality chefs knife, utility knife, paring knife, and a few steak knives are all that you need unless you have a large family with multiple chefs.
Don’t Miss: Steak Of The Month Club Butchers Market
Chicago Cutlery Reviews Wrap Up
What more can we say about a company that has run the gamut of kitchen knife sets? From sets for new home buyers and novice chefs to sets for families and professional cooks? It seems there is no a demographic out there that Chicago Cutlery does not market to. And, now, they have even entered the high-end game, too.
They may never achieve the reverence of a Wusthof Classic or a Kramer by Zwilling J.A. Henckels. It seems that they are certainly going to be making a game stab at it. Hey, if all else fails, at least they are dominating the knife set market, right
How To Contact Chicago Cutlery
Have your eye on a Chicago Cutlery cooking knife set? If you have more questions that go beyond our Chicago cutlery knife set review, you can fill out a contact form on their site or reach out to them through 2 other methods of contact:
- Mail: Corelle Brands, 12000 Molly Pitcher Highway S, Greencastle, PA 17225
Their office hours are Monday to Friday, 9:30 am 4:00 pm.
Need more tools for your kitchen? Get cooking with these trusted brands:
Read Also: Mcdonalds Steak Bagel Sauce Recipe
Is Chicago Cutlery Worth It
Based on this Chicago Cutlery knife set review, we believe their products are definitely worth the buy. If youre looking for affordability and quality, customers adore their knives and knife sets because they perform as expected and last for a long time when properly maintained.
These durable and good-looking knives can make a great addition to any kitchen, whether youre an amateur just starting out or a seasoned professional. Praised for their versatility and durability, Chicago Cutlery and their selection of products get an enthusiastic 2 thumbs up.
Upgrade Pick: Wsthof Classic Ikon Set
*At the time of publishing, the price was $300.
Our testers all favored the Ikon’s classic understated elegance.
The Wüsthof Classic Ikon steak knives arent cheap, but they are the cheapest of the three high-end sets that we tested. With little to distinguish between the high-end sets on performancewhich was universally exceptionalaesthetics played the largest role in this pick, and our testers all favored the Ikon’s classic, understated elegance. Their razor-sharp blades have the ideal upswept shape. The unique double-concave curves of their satiny black POM handles fit the hand wonderfully both our smallest and our largest tester found them the most comfortable to hold of all the knives we tested. Their full-tang construction adds strength and, at 77 grams/2.6 ounces, pleasing heft. Lastly, their construction is flawlessas it should be for the price. Because in truth, its the flawless fit-and-finish, more than anything else, that separates an exceptional luxury steak knife from a really great mid-priced oneand that you pay for.
One criticism: the Ikons come in a simple, clear plastic box. Its sturdy enough to use for knife storage but left us wishing for something more distinguished-looking, particularly if the knives are intended to be a gift. For about $100 more, the blackwood-handled Ikon steak knives come in a walnut case its unfortunate that this is not an option for the standard model.
Don’t Miss: How Long Can Omaha Steaks Stay Frozen
Best Luxury Set: Wsthof Classic Ikon 7
Elegant, sophisticated, ergonomic, sharp as hell. Theres just so much to appreciate about this German-made, handcrafted knife set that includes the four basic knives that a serious home cook needs: an 8-inch chefs knife, 3 1/2-inch paring knife, 6-inch utility knife, 8-inch bread knife, plus come-apart kitchen shears, a 9-inch honing steel and a 15-slot cherry block. This knife set has it all and looks great doing it. Its got history, a classic design and high-tech, high-quality craftsmanship that comes with a lifetime warranty .
The full-tang , triple-riveted polypropylene handles are made for serious wear and tear yet look sleek, with a double bolster that gives them an impressive balance. Thinner than other knives we tested, the handles fit perfectly in a womans hand, but our male tester wished they were a smidge more substantial.
The blades, meanwhile, are a point of differentiation from the other sets. Sure, theyre precision-forged from a single piece of tempered high-carbon stainless steel, making them stain- and corrosion-resistant. So are a few other sets in our testing pool. But their special PEtec edge is created by robots sharpening the blades on a whetstone to a precise and consistent sharpness, making them a self-proclaimed 20% sharper with twice the edge retention, which means youll hardly ever have to sharpen them.
Chicago Cutlery Fusion Forged 18
Chicago Cutlery decided for their cutlery knife set to use two different materials for the handle. The working knives of the Chicago Cutlery Fusion 18-Piece Block Set have a black polyester handle. The Steak knives have a steel handle. The black Asian-influenced, cushion-grip handles provide a sturdy, non-slip grip.For the blades, Chicago Cutlery uses its signature 26-Degree taper grind edge technology. It provides very good sharpness for precise cutting and is easy to re-sharpen. They are forged from high-carbon stainless steel with metal bolsters for added balance and safe handling.The Set Includes:
You May Like: Mcdonalds Bagels Discontinued 2020
Chicago Cutlery Insignia2 18
The Chicago Cutlery Insignia2 knife block set features high-carbon stainless-steel full-tang blades with heavy-duty forged bolsters. This gives the knives a great balance. The handles are made from polymer and are secured with triple stainless-steel rivets to the blade. The design of the handle is quite good. The handle feels good in the hand, and it is super easy to work with the knives. The blades come with what Chicago Cutlery calls the 26-Degree Taper Grind edge. It stands for optimum sharpness, precise cutting, and easy sharpening.There is a built-in knife sharpener in the block, which is quite convenient.
The set includes:
More About Chicago Cutlery Belmont Knives
7.75 Inch Chef Knife
Ultimate versatility. Use for chopping, slicing, dicing and mincing just about any ingredient
8 Inch Bread Knife
Cuts cleanly into firm rinds and crusts without crushing the insides
5 Inch Utility Knife
4.5 Inch Steak Knives
Used for cutting meat at the dinner table. Severs meat fibers cleanly and smoothly
Read Also: Omaha Steaks Delivery Tracking
Pc Chicago Cutlery Block Knife Set
|Stainless Steel, High Carbon Stainless Steel|
- This item: 14 Pc Chicago Cutlery Block Knife Set$31.99Get it $47.20 shippingOnly 1 left in stock – order soon.Ships from and sold by It’sagreatdeal.
- $39.99Get it as soon as Thursday, Jul 14 FREE Shipping on orders over $25 shipped by AmazonIn Stock.
- $8.14Get it as soon as Thursday, Jul 14 FREE Shipping on orders over $25 shipped by AmazonIn Stock.Ships from and sold by Amazon.com.
Budget Pick: Chicago Cutlerys Walnut Tradition Set
*At the time of publishing, the price was $30.
Chicago Cutlerys Walnut Tradition steak knife set is the best low-cost set out there. The knives are not perfect by any metric: the blade-edges are coarse and uneven at 60 grams/2 ounces, theyre a bit lighter than wed like and the fit-and-finish is indifferent. In fact, they appear just to be industrial-grade boning knives with steak knife handles slapped on. Put it this way: if the Messermeisters give you more than you pay for aesthetically, these give you exactly what you pay for, and not a penny more.
They work far better than the serrated blades you usually have to settle for at this price.
But theyre built to last and they work perfectly welland, more importantly, they work far better than the serrated blades you usually have to settle for at this price. Theyre a great choice for outfitting a crowd, taking along on country picnics, or while car camping. Not fancy, perfectly functional, and if you lose one, youll shed no tears.
Read Also: Omaha Steaks Chicken Cordon Bleu Cooking Instructions
Bottom Line: Are Chicago Cutlery Knives Any Good
Now that you know the facts, should you buy Chicago Cutlery?
Are these knives any good?
The main advantage of Chicago Cutlery is its price. Simply put, these knives are cheap. Theyre not your forever knives, but if they dull or chip, you can pick up a new set without breaking the bank.
Sure, you can get better performance with other, more expensive brands, but Chicago Cutlery gets the job done, and they have thousands of happy customers to prove it.
If youre looking for decent knives and youre on a tight budget, Chicago Cutlery is a fine choice.
The downsides of Chicago Cutlery knives are the construction and performance. You wont get the same quality, durability, or edge retention as other brands, such as Wüsthof, Zwilling, or Shun, provide.
If you can afford more expensive knives, I wouldnt recommend Chicago Cutlery. Although other brands cost more, theyre built to last a lifetime. Theyll make cooking prep easier, especially if youre making fresh meals every day.
On that note, if youre looking for comparable alternatives to Chicago Cutlery in terms of price, high-end brands do offer discount lines. Check out the Wüsthof Gourmet collection or the Henckels International collection. Both of these collections are discount stamped knives produced by renowned brands.
If youre still in the market for Chicago Cutlery knives, check out the prices and reviews .