Key Difference Between Kansas City Steaks & Omaha Steaks
The main difference between the two delivery services is in their sourcing practices. Kansas City Steak Company sources 100% grass-fed beef for steaks, while Omaha Steaks finishes their cattle on grain for years.
The Kansas City Steak Company also appears to have USDA Prime, while Omaha Steaks labels their meat cut deals as agency-inspected. Both serve other items such as pork, ham, seafood, plus free-range chicken, based on reviews of Omaha Steaks.
They sure seem to have more game options, including bison and veal cut.
We had even heard rumors that Kansas City steaks were expensive. Still, when we tried out some popular ribeyes and American-style filet mignons a day ago, Omaha Steaks’ deals ended up being more costly in the cart, and it’s something that we’re not used to.
- 100% organic, free-range
Omaha Steaks & Butcherbox Sourcing Practices
We noted above that Omaha Steaks use more choices. But, ButcherBox has better choices if you are on the carnivore diet. I’m a fan of their heritage pork box and breakfast sausage. They offer top-notch grass-fed beef steaks and other beef cuts.
To name a few of the best options are chuck roast, sirloin steaks, beef burgers, strip steaks, bacon, and filet mignon. For fish and seafood lovers, I’ve found their sockeye salmon to be a real treat.
Overall, ButcherBox subscription has a wide variety of meats to choose from. You won’t find yourself tiring as it’s easy to mix and match your custom meal box and purchase it. It won’t even take up much of your time. Just don’t forget to use the paper towels.
Research spanning three decades suggests that grass-based diets can significantly improve the fatty acids composition and antioxidant content of beef
– Amber Abbott, College of Agriculture, California State University
The Best Places To Buy Meat Online
With so many online butcher shops available, choosing one may seem overwhelming. However, having a wide selection is a good thing when it comes to finding the best meat delivery service for you. For those who want to buy meat online for special occasions or without a planned shipping date, consider FarmFoods, Harry and David, and Snake River Farms. Want a monthly meat delivery? Subscription boxesâlike ButcherBox, Carnivore Club, and Porter Roadâare great options if you know you want consistent shipments. If you’re searching for organic, pasture-raised, or grass-fed cuts of meat, our lineup features all of the above. Tip: While you stock up on meat, consider adding plant-based meals into your menu to maintain a healthy lifestyle that’s good for both you and the environment.
Also Check: Wusthof Classic Ikon 6 Piece Steak Knife Set
Best For Wagyu Beef: Crowd Cow
This site was inspired by the concept of purchasing meat directly from a local farmeronly instead of having to buy, transport, and store an entire cow yourself, the animal is crowdfunded between a handful of customers. Shop by independent ranches handpicked for their practices and products, or choose a cut of beef , pork, chicken, lamb, or seafood.
There are also springtime and butcher’s specials, as well as craft meat gifts to send to the meat-lover in your life. Subscribe for free shipping and 5 percent off every order.
Who Would Enjoy Butcherbox
Read Also: What To Marinate Steak With
Is There A Difference In Quality
While both companies also offer high-quality beef, only one specializes in clean eating. ButcherBox’s founding mission was to “make grass-fed beef more accessible.”
Each one of their item in the catalog is clean and free of chemicals and hormones, which makes it a great selection for carnivore dieters. Even when you’re new to the diet, their choices will significantly help in your transition.
The goal is that you can cook a restaurant-grade steak or other great meat in your kitchen. So if you’re looking for top tier cuts, great value, and a rich meaty flavor, I lean towards choosing the box. This is something Omaha Steaks delivery has not guaranteed.
Omaha Steaks also has a quality gourmet meat selection with cuts like NY strip steak, pork tenderloin, and rib-eye steak. But, it doesn’t have the guarantee that their products in a box are clean and additive-free.
However, as a carnivore diet follower, I view meat as more than a food source. It’s the very foundation that provides me energy and sustenance throughout the day. So, food quality is at the top of my list when evaluating these two services. If you’re on the same diet as mine, choose wisely between the quality of Omaha Steaks.
Related Comparison Guides:
Both companies offer custom meal options Omaha Steaks offers gourmet meat packages or pick and choose orders. While ButcherBox has monthly delivery with four main meal kits and a custom box option.
Butcherbox And Omaha Steaks Packaging
Both Butcher Box and Omaha Steaks use the flash-and-freeze technique to preserve all that wonderful, meaty flavor without issue.
Although, a clear difference between the two lies more in the type of packaging used.
Omaha’s approach isstyrofoam while Butcher Box uses a more eco-friendly packaging – biodegradable & recyclable!
Personally, I prefer eco-friendly packaging so Butcher Box takes the lead here.
Also Check: Where To Buy Filet Mignon Steaks
Can You Return Omaha Steaks
Many companies that offer perishable items, from food to wine, have limited return policies. I was pleasantly surprised to find out that Omaha Steaks offers a fairly generous policy where you can request either a replacement or refund the original payment method. You either send an email or call toll-free: 1-800-228-9872. This operates on CST and is available from 7 am to 10 pm on weekdays 8 am to 7 pm on Saturdays, and 9 am to 5 pm on Sundays.
They do have a clause where they reserve rights to limit what they replace or refund. This isnt specified and left open to interpretation. Id prefer them to list reasons why a refund would not be offered.
How Are Omaha Steaks Aged
The majority of their steak is dry-aged for around 20 days, in a temperature and humidity controlled environment. Wet aging is more economical, as it takes mere days. With dry aging, the process takes longer. Wet aging vs dry aging is not as simple as one being superior to the other it depends on the cut of meat. Dry aging is preferred for meat with more fat and marbling, while wet aging is suited for lean cuts, such as flank or flat iron steak.
Also Check: Omaha Steaks Double Stuffed Potatoes
Omaha Steaks Or Kansas City Steaks: Winner
Both Omaha Steaks and Kansas City Steak Company are good, but out of all the similar services weve tried, ButcherBox is still our favourite steak delivery company.
We recommend ButcherBox for their excellent selection of grass-fed beef, free-range organic poultry, heritage-breed pork, and wild-caught seafood.
Aside from offering high-quality meat, we are impressed with the affordability of their subscription model.
Our #1 Recommendation
Does Butcherbox Or Omaha Steaks Have A Better Company Reputation
Later, well take a look at customer reviews. Here, I wanted to look at how long both have been in business, as well as accreditation.
- ButcherBox has been in business for five years, four of which have been accredited through the Better Business Bureau, with an A-plus rating.
- Omaha Steaks has been in business for a century but has offered delivery since the 1950s. The company became accredited in 1967 and also holds an A-plus rating, though lower reviews based on consumer complaints.
Read Also: Kikkoman Teriyaki Steak Marinade Recipe
Omaha Steaks Review: Is Their Meat Really Good
Whether youre getting ready for holidays or simply looking for a great steak, mail-order steaks are more popular than ever. But during a time of uncertaintyand more options to order premium meat than ever beforeis Omaha Steaks worth your time? In this review, Ill give you my honest opinion.
If youve heard of any mail-order steak companies, Omaha Steaks is likely on the top of your list. And theyre doing more than ever to get their name out there both by expanding their inventory and hosting events.
Omaha Steaks hosted a steakation contest in May. The event, which may be repeated in the future, offered a chance to win a mini-retreat all with a steak theme. Contestants were allowed to enter online via Omaha Steaks social media pages.
The prize? A stay in a two-story loft in Omaha, where Omaha Steaks is headquartered. The loft features steak-themed decor and cozy furnishings a sign that they may offer this up again. The lucky winners enjoyed dinner for four people, including you guessed itOmaha Steak products. They were also treated to virtual grilling classes or their choice of a ticket to a local event.
But is Omaha Steaks or any mail order steaks worth your money? This review will discuss ordering steak online and then everything you need to know about the pros and cons of ordering from Omaha Steaks.
Best For Cured Meat: Carnivore Club
Cured meat lovers will be big fans of Carnivore Club. Each month, the subscription service sends customers cured meat from a different artisan vendorso they’ll never receive the same thing twice.
While subscribers cant choose the specific meats they receiveand they need to commit to one month, every other month, or every three monthsthe selections are top-notch. Included in subscriptions are four-to-six cured meats monthly, and theyre ready to eat once unboxed. Meats range from pepperoni and salami to different types of jerky. There are two subscription choices: the Classic Box and the Snack Box. Types of meat found in the Classic Box are garlic salami, smoked soupy, Parmigiano cheese salami, and beer salami. Some meat options found in the Snack Box can include a mango habanero beef jerky, honey Sriracha chicken bites, a pepperoni seasoned stick, and a maple BBQ stick. The monthly subscription fee for the Classic Box is $39.99 plus shipping, while the Snack Box starts at $24.99 plus shipping.
Read Also: How Good Are Omaha Steaks
Shipping Policies: Butcherbox Vs Omaha Steaks
Shipping policies are important for any food subscription, no matter the products.
- Omaha Steaks offers standard and express shipping, all priced by order amount. Charges range from eighteen to fifty dollars . Shipping is available in all fifty United States, Canada and Puerto Rico. You can track your order online at any time.
- ButcherBox offers free standard shipping and you can also track your order online at any time.
What Comes In A Butcher Box:
ButcherBox has a lot of options for what comes in their boxes. Here are some of the options that you can select
- Beef: Stew Beef, Sirloin Tips, Ground Beef, Trip Tip, Burgers, Flat Iron Steaks, Beef Briskey, Bottom Round Roast, Shoulder Roast, Sirloin Cap, Eye of Round Roast, Ranch Steaks, NY Strip Steaks
- Chicken: Whole Chicken, Boneless Skinless Breasts, Chicken Tenders, Boneless or Bone-In Chicken Thighs, Ground Chicken, Drumsticks, Chicken Wings
- Pork: Ground Pork, Breakfast Sausage, Center Cut Pork Loin Roast, Boneless Pork Chops, Pork Sirloin Roasts, Bone in Pork Butt, Bacon, Pork Tenderloin
- Seafood: Salmon, Salmon Burgers, Cod
- Other: Ground Turkey, Ground Bison, Uncured Hot Dogs
When you join ButcherBox right now you can get 1 pack of bacon for free and $20 off your first box!
Recommended Reading: How To Reverse Sear A Steak
Best For Gifts: Omaha Steaks
One of the nations first mail-order meat companies, Omaha Steaks has been slicing and sending specialty steaks across the country for more than a century. The brand is famous for its variety of cuts, like top-notch filet mignons, sirloins, ribeyes, and T-bones, but also has a wide selection of other meats, seafood, sides, dessert, and even wine. It also sells tons of gift packages across a range of price points. From under-$60 gift baskets filled with wine and cheese to a Butchers Share option that sends 95 pounds of Private Reserve beef in multiple shipments, theres something for everyone.
To buy: Starting at $10 omahasteaks.com
Final Thoughts: Who Is Omaha Steaks Right For
Omaha Steaks is one of the tougher reviews weve done. On one hand, their food is delicious and they have quite a lot of variety. On the other hand, the way they price their foods is confusing and can lead to one-off orders being very expensive.
However, my main gripe with Omaha Steaks though is their lack of transparency. Nearly every other meat delivery company we have reviewed in the past has been upfront about where they get their meat, the USDA grade of their meat, and the quality . It was nearly impossible for me to find any information about these things in my research.
With all that said, Omaha Steaks may not be the best value but they do provide the most convenience and variety when compared to nearly every other meat delivery service weve tested. This convenience and variety makes them a great option for people who are hosting big parties, holidays, or get togethers where there will be groups of people eating.
Plus, I cant deny that their food is delicious. Everything weve had in each box weve ordered since 2017 has had an abundance of flavorfrom the filet mignons to the chocolate lava cakes.
Have a questions about Omaha Steaks we didnt answer in this review? Have you tried Omaha Steaks before? Leave your comment below and well get back to you as soon as possible!
Recommended Reading: Best Cuts Of Steak In Order
Holy Grail Steak Co Is A Company That Specializes In Steak
Holy Grail Streak Co, a newcomer to the high-end meat delivery industry, produces the finest American-raised Wagyu with slews of top A5-grade Japanese Waagiu producers on the planet. This includes the ultra-rare Hokkaido Snow Beef and the beloved Kobe BeeF. On the website, you can sort through collections such as Japanese Wagyu, American Waggy U, USDA Prime Black Angus, Akaushi, steak flights, and Waganu burgers.
Holy Grail has an impressive menu, but its not cheap. Your best meat box bet here is purchasing in bulk, like this 12-pound pack of Wagyu burger, for instance, rather than purchasing at reduced prices, which are usually much more expensive. You may purchase one-time boxes or custom orders for yourself, or you may choose from carefully selected beef boxes to send as a gift or care package.
When you spend more than $199, youll receive free ground shipping .
Comparing Omaha Steak & Butcherbox Selection
At first glance, it would seem that Omaha Steaks is the winner when it comes to meat in a box option and different small or big cuts. Indeed they have plenty more to choose from.
Upon closer inspection, I found that the products of Omaha Steaks weren’t always a good option for the carnivore diet. Many of the meats that Omaha Steaks sells are pre-seasoned and come with non-carnivore diet sides.
The options include chicken, beef, and pork. You may save time in seasoning before cooking, but even small condiments are not recommended for carnivore dieters.
With ButcherBox, you are getting the best grass-fed and grass-finished beef, heritage breed pork, and free-range organic chicken strictly. Every meat they use is no doubt hand-picked and of good quality. It’s no-nonsense, and I also don’t have to worry about their meats messing with my diet.
Don’t Miss: Steak N Shake Franchise Owner
Omaha Steaks Pros And Cons
To make sure Omaha Steaks meets all your standards and expectations, it is important to know its biggest advantages and disadvantages. With a short overview of its pros and cons, you can easily decide if Omaha Steaks is the right company for you.
- Hundreds of meat cuts, meals, appetizers, sides, and desserts
- Excellent selection of fine wines
- Vast range of food and wine gifts
- Great rewards program
- Steep shipping fees
Best For Something Wild: Fossil Farms
With a tagline of Wild. Natural. Sustainable. you know youll find some interesting meats on this site. From alligator to yak, youll find options here that you may not find elsewhere, including wild Scottish game, python, and kangaroo.
Of course, there are also more familiar meats, so you can pick up a rib roast or chicken breast and thighs. These won’t be your average dinners, though. Fossil Farms offers meat that’s antibiotic-free, hormone-free, and sustainable.
For many types of meats, from bison to chicken to alligator, you’ll be able to order sausage in addition to whole cuts of meat.
Recommended Reading: How To Make The Best Steak On The Grill
Omaha Steaks Confusing Pricing
Omaha Steaks prices out their foods individually but the bulk of the items can only be bought in multiples. For example, if you wanted to order their Butchers Cut Filet Mignons, the lowest amount you can order is 4 5 oz filets at $74.99.
Things do get a little confusing with the pricing at times because Omaha Steaks is constantly trying to get you to add more items to your cart the whole time youre shopping. For example, I was recently trying to buy their bacon-wrapped filet mignons but at checkout, this is what it said:
To recap, 4 5 oz bacon-wrapped filet mignons came out to $109.99 but if I add any other item to my cart I will save $54.99 . This pricing seems overly complicated in a way to confuse people into buying more.