Thursday, September 14, 2023
HomeOmahaChicago Steaks Vs Omaha Steaks

Chicago Steaks Vs Omaha Steaks

- Advertisment -

What To Know About Cooking

Chicago Steak Company meat review vs Omaha Steaks

One of the big issues Emily and I ran into with Kansas City Steak Company was the cooking process. They give you a booklet that has all of the information needed to make everything from cooking your steaks to heating up the premade dishes.

When we went to cook the steak, we followed the directions outlined in the booklet since we wanted to make sure we were doing everything correctly so they would come out as delicious as possible.

Unfortunately, the was that the booklet lays out the steps, you have to jump between different pages for different steps. For example, on page 10 it tells us the partial instructions for cooking the steak on a skillet. Then you have to jump to page 12 to see how long you need to cook the steak. But on page 12, they have different cooking instructions at the top of the page.

But the most irritating part was that some of the steps dont have spacing between the words. I found it to be pretty tough to actually follow the directions properly because of this.

How Long To Marinade

As little as 20 to 30 minutes will transfer lots of taste to your steaks. I like to get a few hours if I have time. Please refrigerate for food safety.

Up to 8 hours is fine, and some recommend up to 24 hours. But due to the lemon juice and Worcestershire sauce with vinegar, it can affect the texture if marinaded for over 8 hours.

Dont Miss: Steak On A Pellet Smoker

Are Omaha Steaks Precooked

The beef experts at Omaha Steaks select tenderloins for exceptional quality, and then theyre aged at least 21 days to maximize the tenderness of the meat. Thanks to being pre-cooked, all you need to do for the perfect beef tenderloin roast is thaw and heat, or you can also enjoy it at room temperature.

You May Like: Best Place To Buy Skirt Steak

Enjoy Convenience While Supporting Local


FarmFoods is a convenient way to support local farmers. All of the 100% grass-fed and grass-finished beef is sourced from small family-run farms. All farms are listed on the site, so you can shop them directlyor you can choose from individual cuts or value packs. You can purchase beef in bulk or opt for wholesale packs. FarmFoods also offers pasture-raised pork and chicken. All meat arrives frozen.

Donât Miss: Grass Fed Sirloin Steak Price

Filet Mignon Pastry Bites

Chicago Steak Company Reviews: Get All The Details At Hello Subscription!

These are one of the foods you can see us make and taste test in our video review above. For being frozen, these came out delicious. The pastry still had a light crispy and flakey texture, which surprised me for something that was frozen and simply reheated in the oven. The inside filet was juicy and savory. Its definitely something I would order again, especially as an appetizer to be passed out at a party or family get together.

You May Like: What’s The Best Way To Cook A Steak

Cooking Strip Steak In The Oven

  • Preheat the oven to 425 degrees.
  • Heat a cast-iron skillet to medium-high heat with one tablespoon of olive oil.
  • Sprinkle salt and pepper on both sides of the steaks. Add the steaks to the pan, and sear on each side for 2-3 minutes.
  • Transfer the skillet to the middle rack in the oven. Cook for 4-7 minutes, depending on your desired level of doneness.
  • Remove the skillet from the oven, and transfer steaks to a clean plate. Tent the plate with foil, and rest for 5-10 minutes.

Dont Miss: Ninja Steak And Sushi Menu

How Much Does Butcherbox Vs Omaha Steaks Cost

Since there are so many options with Omaha Steaks and ButcherBox is sold differently its hard to directly compare, but Omaha Steaks is actually not that much cheaper

Of course, since ButcherBox includes some cheaper meat, its not a direct comparison, but when you factor in shipping across the board, minus sales, you may not save much with Omaha Steaks vs ButcherBox. ButcherBox seems to me to be the better deal.

Dont Miss: How Long Can Omaha Steaks Stay Frozen

Don’t Miss: Which Is The Best Steak To Eat

A Flexible Service With Affordable Pricing


Porter Road is based out of Kentucky, which is where the company processes its meats. All meat is sourced from pastures in Kentucky, Tennessee and Pennsylvania and free of antibiotics and hormones. Its also dry-aged and hand-cut at Porter Roads own facilities.

For meat delivery, you have a few different options. You can pick and choose the beef, pork, lamb and/or chicken cuts you want, sign up for a subscription or get a curated box with Porter Roads favorites. The company also has bundled boxesincluding a Stay At Home Bundlethat make great gifts for family friends across the country. Most meat, with the exception of sausages, ground beef and large roasts, arrives fresh.

Just What Makes A Smoked Steak

Omaha Steaks vs Chicago Steak Company

While smoking steaks may seem like a new age phenomenon, perfected by those TV food stars with loads of BBQ awards and impeccably trimmed beards, it turns out smoking meat is a technique that dates back to ancient times. While in the modern era of refrigerators, smoking steak tends to be less of an exercise in necessity, but the process is still used to impart a host of BIG flavors and nuanced changes in texture to your already delectable cuts of beef.

The technique of smoking refers to the process of burning a variety of woods in an enclosed space over low heat where the meat can cook slowly and take on flavors from the charcoal, fruit or other hard woods.

Smoked steak recipes usually begin with a dedicated meat smoker, a piece of equipment you can buy online or at your local BBQ specialty store. A charcoal grill can also be adapted to smoke meat using items found in your local home improvement store, like a special grill grate and hickory chips. While both of these methods will result in authentic, delicious and flavorful meat, when it comes to how to smoke a steak at home from the comfort of your kitchen, we have a few handy shortcuts up our sleeves.

Recommended Reading: Laguiole Jean Dubost 6 Piece Steak Knife Block Set

Read Also: Larry’s Steaks Menu Rising Sun

Kansas City Steak Vs Omaha Steak

Love meat, but hate shopping? Thats where auto-delivery comes in.

Certain Kansas City Steaks items are available as part of a subscription of sorts. That means you can get your meats and sides delivered on a frequency schedule that fits your needs. The brand offers 4, 8, 12, and 16 week delivery periodsand did we mention that all auto-ship orders are sent for free?

If at any time you want to skipa shipment or pause while youre out of town, you can easily through your account. If there comes a time when you no longer want to receive shipments, youll be able to cancel without penalty.

What Is The Best Steak

Best Beef: Top 10 Steak CutsPorterhouse. This particular steak is considered the king of steaks, mainly because there are actually two steaks in one. T-ben. This steak is named after its T-shaped leg. This is a relatively lean piece of steak. Tri-Type flank. New York Strip. Filet mignon. Ribbed eye.

You May Like: Omaha Steaks Filet Mignon Recipe

Recommended Reading: Best Tomahawk Steak In Miami

Omaha Steaks Vs Butcherbox

CONTENTSTimothy Woods

Both Butcher Box and Omaha Steaks are well recognized for their high quality meat and great meal delivery services.

However, many people claim that the two have some subtle differences that make one slightly more advantageous than the other.

We decided to put this claim to the test, and after many hours of research and three-month-long testing, weve gathered a few interesting facts for you.

Lets discuss both Butcher Box and Omaha Steaks below.

What Grocery Store Sells The Best Steak

How To Cook Prime Rib Steak

The best grade of beef is Prime, and organic grass-fed is premium in terms of meat quality, taste & health. Unfortunately prime beef is only available in small quantities to grocers like Wegmans or Whole Foods Market due to low demand due to its premium price. But the best nationwide grocer for steaks is Whole Foods.

Read Also: Omaha Steak Twice Baked Potato Directions

Chicago Steak Shipping Fees

The only genuine downside of the Chicago Steak Company is that they charge fees for every package shipped, although they’re known to offer free shipping promo codes often, so watch out for those. While they charge fees for one-off purchases, shipping is free with subscriptions.

With such high-end meat delivery services, paying the shipping fees shouldn’t be much of a problem. We recommend you visit their official website if you want to get up to date with shipping information, including discounts and shopping coupons.

Related Reviews and Comparison Guides:

Omaha Steaks Boneless Heart Of Prime Rib Roast Vs Kansas City Steaks Prime Rib Roast Review:

Omaha Steaks Boneless Heart of Prime Rib Roast

This is a head-to-head comparison of two steak companies that are so proud of their prime slabs of meat that they each include steak in their companys name.

Its only fitting that I get into the juicy details of each brands juiciest cuts in this Omaha Steaks vs Kansas City Steaks review. Get out your cleavers and bibs, this one is about to get bloody.

The Omaha Steaks Boneless Heart of Prime Rib Roast is a family gathering in the form of meat. The brand wants you to take it easy when it comes time to indulge in this fatty delight. Theyve done the honors of carving it for you.

This steak is flash-frozen to preserve its freshness. That also makes preparation easy. You can slice it as is, or throw it between two slices of bread and make yourself a mock Philly Cheesesteak.

Additionally, the Omaha Steaks Boneless Heart of Prime Rib Roast has been aged for nearly a month, turning into a ticking time bomb of flavor. Omaha Steaks even went the extra mile and trimmed this roasts exterior fat layer for you.

It comes in 4lbs and 8lbs sizes.

Kansas City Steaks Prime Rib Roast

By comparison, the Kansas City Steaks Prime Rib Roast is available in sizes from 3.5lbs to 6lbs. While thats a bit smaller, this roast isnt lacking in its own powerful flavor.

  • Garlic and Herb Prime Rib Roast
  • Traditional Rib Roast
  • Roasted Steakhouse Rub Prime Rib

Recommended Reading: French Steak Knives With Bee

Our Kansas City Steak Reviews

USDA Choice Ribeye 10 oz. $20 ea.Each boneless Ribeye Steak is carved from the aged Prime Rib Roast, an unbelievably tender and tasty cut.Ribeye served with MushroomsUSDA Ungraded Prime Rib Roast 3.5 lbs $80 3 Steaks 19 oz. for $27Filet Mignon served with Potatoes and SpinachUSDA Choice Super Trimmed Filet Mignon 8 oz. $27.50 ea.cut from the center of the finest aged tenderloinSteak MatchmakerKansas City Strip Steak served with Potatoes and SpinachUngraded Kansas City Strip Steak 12 oz. $24 ea.Our Conclusion

Submitted Customer Experiences

We tried the Sirloin and the Porterhouse steaks. The flavor was excellent on both but they we so very thin. It was extremely difficult to barbeque them a true medium rare to rare. We did notify them of this issue. We are extremely pleased with their response. They explained why the steaks were cut that way. Also, they stated the the filets are the only cut of meat that are much thicker. They also suggested that they send us Custom Filets or a 50% discount on our order. We chose the filets. They are truly awesome. Thank you so much for your incredible customer service.Kansas City Steaks was horrible. Even after I complained customer service suggested I should have ordered a more premium cut. spent over $300 for gristle porterhouse and 1/2 thick ribeyes. in my opinion it was like ordering minute steaks in the 60s.I purchased a 5 to 5.5 lb prime rib roast. WI purchased a Porterhouse steak.

Comparing The Menu Options

Omaha Steaks vs Rastelli Direct

Both companies have similar nice classic beef and quality meats, such as New York strip steak, filet mignon, ribeyes, top sirloin, prime rib, and a T-bone with really tasty flavor.

They both also offer high-grade seafood, free-range chicken, turkey, and Berkshire pork for meat delivery.

We love how they both offer exclusive Black Angus all year long, as well.

We say that’s one good meal you would want to try and share with your family or give as a gift to close friends.

For your party, you can add wine, a variety of country dish sides, and everything’s perfect.

For the purpose of ourOmaha Steaks review, we found out that the business may have a more extensive menu that you can place an order on. They offer bison, veal, wet-aged beef, and gourmet burgers for you to cook.

Don’t Miss: Omaha Steaks Breaded Veal Patties

How Does Shipping And Handling Work For Kansas City Steaks Vs Omaha Steaks

A mail-order steak company offers excellent cuts of steak but if their delivery and shipping policies are not convenient, inefficient, or dishonest, it can ruin the entire experience. I also always check the shipping and handling to ensure that the company delivers in certain locations, and to understand the total cost you can be expected to pay.

Which Is Better Ribeye Or Filet Mignon

A simplified rule to remember is: the ribeye is perfect for those who prefer flavor, and the filet mignon is the better choice for those who prefer texture. Ribeye has long been known to steak lovers as the epitome of steak flavor. This cut of meat comes from the ribs of the animal, between the loin and shoulder.

Recommended Reading: Kansas City Steak Company Phone Number

Also Check: Allen Brothers Vs Omaha Steaks

How Long Does Omaha Steaks Foods Stay Good In Their Packaging

Weve held on to frozen Omaha Steaks meat for over 3 months since purchasing it and havent had any issues cooking it after. Its important to note that the meat has to stay frozen through this whole time, since it can spoil thawing and being refrozen. Omaha Steaks says that their meats are vacuum sealed to last for up to three months in a properly working freezer.

Read Also: How To Cook Steak On George Foreman Grill

How We Chose The Best Meat Delivery Services

Premium Angus Beef

Here at Forbes Vetted, we scour the market to make sure were only recommending the best of the bestand those same standards were upheld as we crafted this list of the best meat delivery services. We sorted through thousands of firsthand reviews from consumers, compared prices and generally determined whether the services we selected were of an exceptionally high value. This story was last updated in September 2022.

Recommended Reading: Sizzler Steak And Malibu Chicken

Heres What Customers Are Saying

User reviews for both companies were somewhat mixed, but we encountered more positive testimonials for Butcher Box than Omaha Steaks:

I must say I love Butcher Box. I have tried many different meat companies in the past year or so, and so far they have been the best.

Brett P

On Trustpilot

The site gives you flexibility in choosing your next box meat selections, as well as ship date, and shipping frequency. Without exception, I receive my box within 1-2 business days after the billing date.– Sabrina MOn Trustpilot

I realized that the box saves me a lot of time at the supermarket and I reckon their prices are pretty similar to budget places like Costco.- Kristen F

The Types Of Food Omaha Steaks Offers

While steaks are in their name, Omaha Steaks offers way more than just steak. In fact, they offer nearly every cut of beef, chicken, turkey, and pork imaginable. But thats just a portion of the foods they offer. They also now offer seafood, pastas, sides, desserts, and even wine.

To give you an idea of the immense variety they offer, here are some of their most popular foods they sell from each category:


The examples above are really just the tip of the iceberg. In fact, I found one of the hardest parts of ordering to be deciding what to get.

While they offer a lot of meats that you cook, a good portion of the items they offer are premade foods .

This enormous variety, coupled with their premade options makes Omaha Steaks a great option for special occasions where you may need to feed a lot of people a nice dinner but you dont want to have to spend hours cooking everything. Emily and I have considered using Omaha Steaks for when we host future family holidays.

By Dan Scalco Last Updated: May 21, 2021 Affiliate Disclosure

Kansas City Steak Company Review

Product Name: Kansas City Steak Company

  • Food Box HQ Rating

Bottom Line

Kansas City Steaks was a bit of a letdown. We paid close to $90 for 4 8oz steaks that were just okay. The funny part was the desserts ended up being our favorite item that we ordered from a steak company.


They offer a ton of varietyfrom meats to sides to desserts.

Some foods were very delicious .


The packaging could be better.

Recommended Reading: Does Omaha Steaks Take Food Stamps

Best For Small Households: Rastellis

Courtesy of Rastellis

Want the convenience of having steaks shipped directly to your home, but dont have the cold storage space to commit to a large shipment? Rastellis offers single servings of USDA prime-graded bone-in porterhouse, ribeye, filet mignon, and New York strip steaks with no minimum purchase quantity, so you can buy exactly how much meat you need.

Rastellis has a rich 40-year history in butchery and now works with Midwestern family-run farms and ranches to bring pastured meat that is certified humane and verified by the Non-GMO Project. The company still cuts and ages all of its beef in house. All meat is vacuum-sealed and shipped frozen, so you can store it in the freezer or thaw it in the refrigerator for immediate use.

Porter Road is driven by a mission to source high-quality meat from local ranches. Located in Kentucky, it sources pasture-raised cattle from Kentuckian and Tennessean ranches that have high standards for both animal husbandry and environmental concerns.

All steaks are cut and dry-aged for at least 14 days. Dry aging is a process in which steak is exposed to air so that some of its moisture evaporates and the beef flavor concentrates and intensifies. Each of the steak listings features a guide for the cut, so you can learn about which part of the cattle it comes from and the best cooking method to use.

Read Also: Does Olive Garden Serve Steak

- Advertisment -

Most Popular

- Advertisment -