Easy Reverse Seared Ribeye Steak In The Oven
May 22, 2022
A perfectly cooked, full-flavored, tender, and juicy Reverse Seared Ribeye Steak is glorious and the ultimate steak dinner. In this easy recipe, a bone-in ribeye steak is first roasted low-and-slow in the oven and then pan-seared in a cast-iron skillet on the stove until it develops a tasty crust.
Bone-in ribeye steaks are known for their exceptional beefy taste and beautiful marbling. They are perfect for reverse searing, and the best part is this cooking method is easy enough even for novice cooks.
Ribeye steaks are my favorite cut of beef. The outside edge, called the ribeye cap or spinalis, is the richest, most tender part. While beef tenderloin or filets are considered the most tender cut of beef, ribeyes are, by far, the most flavorful.
If you like them grilled, you might also want to check out my recipe for Smoked Ribeye Steak.
How To Remove The Bone
Whether you forgot to have the butcher remove the bone for you or you simply wanted to face the challenge yourself, removing the bone is a relatively straightforward process to do if you are no expert, even from home.
Ideally, youd use a thin and sharp boning knife. In a pinch, a fillet blade will work. Heres how you do it:
Make your cut going upwards, then downwards
Position the meat in your hands so that the thin side of the slab is up and the bone and flat surface are able to be seen. With the sharp edge of your knife facing up, insert the knife into the flesh and keep it as close as possible to the bone itself. Remain steady hands and apply firm pressure as you are making your cut. With a good quality knife, you should get an even and smooth slice. Apply minimal pressure to avoid ant jerky motions or uneven slices.
Once the top of the ribeye is bone-free, flip the knife the opposite way and make a slice going downwards to further separate the meat from the bone. Once completed correctly, you should feel the top rib. The top rib is a portion of the bone that usually extends further into the flesh of the meat.
Make your final cut around the top rib
With the same knife, cut in an L motion around the top rib. If done correctly and smoothly, your ribeye should be separated from the bone.
Are Their Flavors Different
Because the prime rib and eye portions are similar pieces of meat coming from the same part of the cow, youre not going to find significant differences in their flavor. Theyre both filled with rich, beefy flavors thanks to their fat and muscle content. However, the prime rib typically contains more bone and fat, which might give it a slight edge over the eye in terms of flavor. Bone-in ribeye, though, also benefits from the natural flavoring that comes from being cooked with the bone, so its flavor doesnt stray far from the prime rib.
Youll notice the most significant flavoring differences in how you choose to cook a beef ribeye or prime rib. While most people enjoy the eye with a little bit of salt and pepper and a reverse sear with some olive oil, the prime rib gets a bit more experimental. From broil to sous vide with natural juices, the prime rib has several cooking options that can change up the flavor quite a bit.
Recommended Reading: Country Fried Steak Sam’s Club
The Case For Why A Bone
Boneless ribeyes have become increasingly more popular in recent times. Many would agree that newer generations more enjoy boneless steaks, and bone-in steaks are for the classic and traditional meat-eaters.
Boneless steaks take significantly less time to cook thoroughly, due to the fact that it has less muscle and minimal connective tissue. Boneless steaks are considered easier to cook and ready to eat in less time because less heat has to penetrate into the multiple layers of the steak.
Also, its easier to create firm contact between your meat and grill grates or sear pan with a boneless cut.
A boneless steak is often a little less juicy than a bone-in steak due to the fact that a bone-in steak contains juices and fats that are responsible for a lot of the flavors and textures. This also means that boneless steaks are much easier to chew since it is softer.
A significant benefit of removing the bone from your ribeye is that doing so exposes more surface on the cut for seasonings to penetrate through. Seasonings play a huge roll in making the meat more flavorful and delectable.
Many cooks swear by fresh thyme and rosemary when cooking ribeye. When paired with sizzling butter, crushed garlic, and sea salt, the flavor is immaculate.
Some ribeye fanatics argue that the bone adds no flavor at all, especially when it is prepared by roasting or smoking it. When going with a dry cooking method, leaving the bone in does not add much flavor improvement.
To Our Valued Customers
We regret that due to technical challenges caused by new regulations in Europe, we can for the time being no longer accept orders from the European Union. If you reside in the UK you can continue to order from our UK websites or shop from our locations and partners. Visit West Elm at www.westelm.co.uk and Pottery Barn Kids at www.potterybarnkids.co.uk.
Matters of consumer privacy and rights are paramount to our brands and we will continue to work diligently to make our products available to you. The pace of global regulations is hard to predict, but we have the ultimate goal of being able to offer our products everywhere.
We share your disappointment and greatly appreciate your understanding. Thank you for your patronage.
Don’t Miss: How Long Will Omaha Steaks Stay Frozen During Shipping
Why Does A Ribeye Have So Much Flavor
It absolutely starts with the quality. Prime beef is the highest quality steak in the world. The abundance of marbling in a Prime ribeye steak adds to the flavor. And thats where many steak connoisseurs insist that a ribeye is a cut above the rest.Especially in a marbled cut of beef like a ribeye, much of the distinctively rich, meaty taste actually comes from the fat. But its what happens with the fat both in the particular aging process and in preparation that really brings out the flavor. Depending on how you like your steak cooked, which is of course personal preference, slightly more or slightly less marbling in a ribeye can enhance the flavor even more.
Best Wine Pairing With A Ribeye Steak
Typically a highly marbled steak like a ribeye will need a moderately robust wine to complement it best.
We might recommend a young Cabernet Sauvignon, for example, or one that is equally approachable through its maturity like wines from Napas Caymus Vineyards. That said, our award-winning wine list has a number of Cabernets by the bottle or glass, and its fun to try your own expertise at pairing your favorite wines with various cuts of Prime steak.
For those who prefer a lighter wine, a Zinfandel or a nice Malbec from Chile or Argentina would also make a nice alternative to a Cab.
While wine pairings are another topic that often sparks a spirited discussion among some, we truly believe that personal preference is still what matters most. If a full-bodied Cab just isnt your taste and you prefer a lighter, more delicate varietal like a Pinot Noir, then order what youll enjoy the most with this exceptional cut of beef.
Recommended Reading: Larry’s Steaks Menu Rising Sun
The Case For Leaving The Bone In
The great debate surrounding ribeye is whether the bone matters or not. Many sources and cooks claim that leaving the meats bone in makes it juicer and adds a ton of flavor to the meat. The knowledgable advocates for bone-in ribeye say that the bone marrow contains much of the flavor that is seeped into the steak as it is being cooked.
The meat that is touching the bone requires a higher temperature or longer cook times to cook thoroughly. The chefs who prepare their steaks medium to be hot will argue that the meat closer to the bone is more juicy and tender because it is less cooked.
The bone is made of temperature-maintaining properties that allow the meat to stay in a heat range where the meat is most tender and moist. The texture and consistency of beef are all dictated by the temperature of which it is cooked.
To further back up the bone-in side of the argument, researchers from Texas A& M University discovered that leaving the bone in your ribeye allows it to hold its shape much better.
Cooking bone-in ribeyes can seem intimidating on the surface however, these cuts do not require any unusual cooking method. The only difference from cooking boneless ribeye is that bone-in ribeyes need a longer time to cook because the bone can interrupt and slow down the heat distribution.
This cooking characteristic can actually come in handy since it causes the meat to reach its peak temperature at a gradual pace. Overcooking bone-in ribeyes is highly unlikely.
What Is Prime Rib And Where Does It Come From
Prime rib is also known as a standing rib roast. The roast comes from the same part of the animal that the ribeye does: the primal rib section. If you are at a restaurant and ask for the prime rib you will get a slice of meat from the cooked roast most likely. It is also important to note that although prime rib contains prime in its name, this does not mean that it is USDA Prime beef. Be sure to double-check the grading of your beef before you purchase it to make sure youre actually buying USDA Prime beef if thats what youre after.
The prime rib is well-marbled throughout its meat, meaning that it has a decent amount of fat content that renders down as it cooks to keep the beef tender. A popular way to cook the rib is with au jus, or in its own juices, to prevent it from getting dry during the cooking process as it reaches your desired temperature.
Don’t Miss: Omaha Steaks Dry Ice Disposal
What Is A Bone In Ribeye Steak
It is a cut of beef, usually taken from the ribs with the bone left in. Sometimes called cowboy steaks or Scotch fillets, they are usually grilled or broiled.
What does it look like?
It can be whole Bone in steaks that contain everything but the T-bone and/or filet mignon portion of the short loin subprimal although most often they are boneless subprimals consisting of eye round, sirloin tip, top butt, etc., removed from the longissimus thoracis .
What nutrients are included?
The Bone in ribeye steak is mostly meat, and also contains some fat around the edges.
In addition to various vitamins and minerals, boneless steak contains lean protein, omega 3 fatty acids, calcium, phosphorus, zinc magnesium and potassium.
Move To Indirect Heat Area Of Grill
Once you have properly seared the steak, if it is not finished, move it to the side of the grill where it not directly over the coals. Close the lid and continue cooking the steak until you achieve the temperature you desire. Keep in mind that you do not need to flip the steak during this stage of indirect grilling.
Don’t Miss: Mcdonalds Steak Egg And Cheese Bagel Recipe
What Makes This Recipe So Good
- The reverse-sear method is the best way to cook ribeyes. Hands-down, period, no questions asked, end of story. This low-and-slow method gets you perfect, evenly-cooked, juicy, tender steak with a slightly crisp edge every single time.
- Are bone-in steaks better than boneless steaks? Better is a matter of preference, but theres no use pretending bone-in steaks arent amazing. The bone adds so much flavor and moisture to the meat. They take a little longer to cook than boneless steaks, but trust me, its completely worth it.
- Its super easy to put together, but looks elegant and tastes incredible. That makes it perfect for special occasions like anniversaries, date-nights, celebrations, or Valentines Day. Even the delicious garlic herb butter will blow you away!
- Everything you need for this recipe is available at Sprouts Farmers Market! One-stop shopping is a big deal in my book, and when Im planning out meals for the week, I always prioritize recipes that dont have me running all over town picking up one ingredient here and one ingredient there.
Is Cowboy Steak The Same As Tomahawk Steak
Cowboy steak or should I call it Tomahawk steak is a cut of hamburger ribeye that has the entire rib bone connected, and its occasionally called a rancher steak or bone-in ribeye. The fundamental distinction between a ribeye is the visual show. Besides, a cowboy steak is in many cases cut more than 2-inches thick to oblige the bone.
A cowpoke steak is a thick bone-in ribeye cut between the ribs and feeds 1-2 without any problem. Likewise, with all our meat, these cuts come exclusively from the upper 1/3 of Choice, and Prime grades.
On the off chance that you like bone-in steaks, for example, T-bone or Porterhouse, youll cherish the Tomahawk Steak as the essential back muscle, which is additionally the fundamental muscle on the T-bone and Porterhouse.
A Tomahawk steak is a bone-in Ribeye, taken from the rib region. The butcher can now and again take out the bone, leaving the boneless Ribeye cut. The most straightforward method for separating Tomahawk steak versus Ribeye steak is through the presence of a bone a Tomahawk Ribeye steak is on the bone, and Ribeye isnt.
The reason why its so costly is that its ready from the ribeye. Bone-in ribeyes are enormous, good steaks cut from the forequarter rib segment of the hamburger. This hamburger cut is really delicate due to the marbled fat spread all through the meat and is definitely worth its cost!
Also Check: Creamy Dill Mustard Mcdonalds
Your Guide To Cooking Ribeye Steak
Ribeye is one of the worlds most favorite steak cuts because of its taste and texture. And, its relatively simple to cook with your chosen method, like grilling or pan-searing. If youd like to try some of the best ribeye cuts that your money can buy, check out the ribeye selection at Chicago Steak Company.
How To Cook A Bone
Looking for a delicious and decadent way to cook your next steak? Look no further than this bone-in ribeye recipe. Rich in marbling and flavor, this steak is sure to please even the most discerning of palates.
- Optional: garlic, rosemary and thyme
- Prep time
Read Also: Canada Steak Burger In Chula Vista
Whats The Difference Between A Rib
Both steaks come from the section of beef cattle which is located between the front legs. A rib-eye has the bones near the front of the animal, where the cow is allowed to eat the most expensive forage, while a t-bone has the bones farther back, where the animal is typically fed more generic forage. Additionally, a rib-eye has a more prominent strip of fat running lengthwise along the outer edge of the steak.
The difference between the two cuts mainly lies in the level of tenderness. A rib-eye steak is generally more tender and flavorful than a t-bone. However, due to the bone and location of the strip of fat running down the outside of the steak, a rib-eye is also generally more expensive than a t-bone.
The First Rule Of Steak House What Kind Of Steak Should I Grill
Its all about sourcing good ingredients. You must first begin with good-quality beef and the right cut. If you get good meat your grilled steaks will shine without any elaborate flavorings or tenderizers.
When choosing the right steak look to the USDAs grading system to assess quality. Beef thats labeled Prime is superior Choice is next in the quality ranking and lastly is Select dont bother if this is all thats available.
Recommended Reading: Pee Dee Steak House On 125 Menu
To Carve And Serve The Bone
Run your knife along the bone to cut away the meat. Cut the steak at a 45-degree angle into 1/2-inch slices.
Place the meat next to the bone on a large plate, sprinkle with kosher salt, and drizzle with lime juice, if desired. Pair/ with Honey Sriracha Sauteed Vegetable Medley, Red Salsa “Mexican Restaurant Style” on the side, and our Delicious Paraguayan Homemade Sausage. Enjoy!
Best Thermometer For Cooking Multiple Cuts Of Meat: Tranmix Wireless Meat Thermometer
You dont need two meat thermometers if youre cooking several cuts of meat at once. You need the Tranmix Wireless Meat Thermometer. This wireless thermometer comes with two probes, which you can stick in two different pieces of meat cooking simultaneously. Set the desired temperature for each cut and then walk away and wait for the alarm to sound when each piece is done cooking.
Advertiser Disclosure: When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.
More From ConsumerSearch.com
Also Check: How Do I Track My Omaha Steaks Order
Can You Make A Grilled Ribeye Rub Beforehand
You most definitely can. The Montreal blend used for this grilled ribeye recipe can actually be kept at room temperature indefinitely, so long as its kept in a cool, dry place.
You can even apply the rub and refrigerate overnight. It wont be a dry marinade at that point, but thats okay. The result will be the same, and youll get the same crust and sear.